How's this for a contradiction: The Friends of the Santa Clara River have sued the Castaic Lake Water Agency , alleging that the CLWA's decision to buy more water means we'll have less water.
Follow that?
In a lawsuit that amounts to a demand that the CLWA become a growth management tool, the Friends of the Santa Clara River are claiming that the CLWA's decision to buy $48 million worth of the clear stuff from the State Water Project will encourage the development of too many homes in the Santa Clarita Valley— and that, as a result, local underground water supplies will in the future be overdrafted.
Taking this argument a step further, then, it becomes clear that the Friends of the Santa Clara River are arguing that it's the CLWA's responsibility to stop residential construction in the SCV by refusing to attempt to prepare an adequate water supply to serve a larger population.
That's wrong on a number of levels.
Perhaps most importantly, it is not, in any way, the water agency's job to control growth. It is the water agency's job to provide a safe, reliable water supply, and to do its level best to meet anticipated demands. Buying the rights to additional state water can only mean one thing: In the event of a drought, the Santa Clarita Valley will be entitled to a greater amount of water.
In drought years, the state cuts back the percentages of entitlements that water agencies receive. For example, in some drought years the CLWA might receive half its entitlement. By increasing the size of its regular entitlement, the CLWA will also increase the amount of water it gets in those drought years.
The question of whether the valley's underground water supplies will be overdrafted during droughts is, in fact, a valid one that warrants addressing— and should be taken into account by those entities that hold governing authority over new development proposals.
But it's ludicrous to suggest that the CLWA should unilaterally halt residential development by refusing to attempt to secure a more reliable supply of state water— a commodity that, ironically, is intended to help reduce the valley's reliance on underground supplies.
One can't help but wonder if there is some other motive at work in such a legal challenge.
