Talk about full. The valley's high schools are loaded beyond the max, and even with two new high schools expected to open in the next half-decade , the campuses are expected to continue to be filled at or beyond capacity.
As a result, the board of trustees for the William S. Hart Union High School District has unanimously voted to suspend the district's open enrollment program that has allowed students to transfer from one school to another within the district without having to justify the move to school officials.
"The reason we've made the recommendation is every school is over capacity," said Michael Allmandinger, administrator of student services for the district. "It simplifies the whole process by not leading people on that there's going to be any room."
Added Superintendent Robert Lee : "I think for a temporary hiatus it's a good move to see where we are."
Lee further noted that intra-district transfers will still be available to those students who can demonstrate a legitimate need to transfer to another school.
All of this reasoning is sound, and the school board made the right move: When all of the schools are full anyway, it doesn't make sense to allow for the possibility of a large number of open enrollment transfers that may exacerbate an overcrowding problem at a particular campus. By suspending open enrollment for the 2000-2001 school year, the district gives itself the ability to better manage student load.
And, while they're at it, may we make a suggestion to the Hart district: With the suspension of open enrollment should also come a serious evaluation of the apparent abuses that have occurred as large numbers of students appear to transfer to different schools not for academic reasons, but for athletic ones.
There is no small degree of resentment within various portions of the community where citizens believe " all-star " athletic programs have been facilitated by open enrollment. Obviously, athletics are an important part of high school and a valuable aspect of the educational process. However, good sense has been turned on its ear when one hears grumblings about individuals— sometimes parents— "recruiting" a star athlete at the high school level.
Admittedly, the school district's hands are somewhat tied. So long as schools in a district have space, state law requires them to allow for open enrollment. So the Hart district has done nothing "wrong" in its handling of open enrollment transfers.
But that law clearly wasn't created with the intention of facilitating the construction of a powerhouse football team at one school, and a championship baseball team at another, an unbeatable basketball team at another... and so on.
The law was created to offer students academic choice. And given the inevitable variables from one campus to the next— despite educators' best efforts to provide equal programs for all— there is merit to providing such a choice. It may indeed even prove impossible to provide that choice without also providing it to students whose motives are purely sports-related .
But perhaps, before the Hart District finds itself in a position of reinstating open enrollment, it can evaluate the frequency of transfers that have appeared to be solely for athletic reasons, and perhaps provide that information to state legislators who may take an interest in revamping California's open enrollment law to refocus its emphasis to its rightful place:
Academics.
