A judge’s ruling delaying the development of the 21, 600-home Newhall Ranch development raises nearly as many questions as it answers.
The Bakersfield Superior Court ruling Wednesday sent The Newhall Land and Farming Co. back to the drawing board in several key areas, casting doubt over the future of the proposed 19-square-mile development west of Interstate 5.
Both sides claimed to be pleased with the ruling, and Newhall Land officials publicly indicated they plan to address the judge’s concerns by revisiting the project’s environmental impact report in the next year.
But the fact is, the future of Newhall Ranch is very much in doubt— perhaps most notably as it relates to the issue of water availability.
The judge in the case told Newhall Land it would have to better demonstrate that adequate water resources will be available at build-out — either by securing new sources of water or by demonstrating that the local underground aquifer can store injected water.
Making predictions in any case is dicey business, and it is particularly so when it comes to predicting the future availability of water. Even though the master development’s individual projects would have to again go before Los Angeles County for approval, the court has held that the developer must essentially guarantee water availability for three decades. Newhall Land, if nothing else, faces a tall order.
Does that mean the ruling was a fatal blow to Newhall Ranch? In all likelihood, no.
It does raise questions about how Newhall Ranch will be developed, and by whom. Anyone who believes the Santa Clarita Valley’s growth will not continue along the State Route 126 corridor— or believes growth can be stopped altogether— is kidding himself.
That doesn’t mean issues like water availability should be dismissed without adequate investigation, but the fact remains that the territory west of Santa Clarita is likely to be developed— if not as Newhall Ranch, then as something else.
What would that something else be? What are the options? Might Newhall Land sell off the property to a series of developers, each of which would then go to Los Angeles County for piecemeal approval of developments rather than the master-planned approach of Newhall Ranch? Would that really be preferable?
Obviously, legitimate concerns like water availability and the development’s impact on the Santa Clara River must be addressed. To advocate anything less would be foolhardy.
The court ruling has raised a host of questions about how those and other issues will be settled— and for now, the only thing certain about Newhall Ranch is uncertainty.
