In virtually any election, it would have been considered a landslide victory, a convincing tally in which the opposition would have been termed “knocked out.”
“Yes” votes: 10,615.
“No” votes: 5,443.
Statistically, it was a remarkable achievement. Very few political candidates or issues actually earn such weighty numbers. Measure S earned the approval of nearly two voters for every one who voted against it. Such totals are impressive in any election.
Suppose, for example, a president was elected by such a margin in the popular vote, capturing 66.1 percent of the ballots cast. We’d be using words like “mandate” and “landslide.”
Instead, we’re talking failure.
Measure S was the $52 million bond measure that would have enabled the William S. Hart Union High School District to build three new high schools and two new junior highs, as well as refurbishing the district’s aging campuses.
The initiative would have meant much more to the district than $52 million. It would have brought $143 million in state matching funds— state tax dollars that will only be spent here if we approve a local bond measure.
Many of those who opposed Measure S were either misinformed or refused to listen to the facts: As much as we’d all like to “make the developers” pay for schools, state law limits what can be required of developers. Further, developer contributions can’t be required to repair existing campuses, and state construction funds simply are not doled out unless a community approves a local bond. Period. No local bond, no state money.
The rules were stacked against Measure S and the Hart District.
Just as it was in November with Measure A, this bond measure narrowly missed approval: It needed 66.7 percent and it pulled down 66.1 percent of the votes cast.
And just as it was in November, only 33.9 percent of the voters made the decision for all of us.
Because of the state law requiring two-thirds approval for local school bonds, it takes little more than a third of the vote to deny Santa Clarita Valley students the opportunity to go to schools that have adequate classroom space and the proper amenities for a productive learning environment.
Now, that minority has denied the Hart District twice. And until the rules change, that will probably be the end of it. After two narrow failures, the district isn’t too likely to go back for a third try under the existing rules.
There is talk in Sacramento of a November ballot initiative that would decrease the approval requirement from two-thirds to 55 percent. Ideally, the law would be changed to require a simple majority— this is, after all, supposed to be a democratic process. But Proposition 26, which would have put a simple-majority rule in place, was narrowly defeated at the state polls in March.
Perhaps if the 55-percent rule is enacted we’ll see another bond measure from the Hart District, and there will be hope after all for Santa Clarita Valley high schools and junior highs.
In the meantime, what awaits the Hart District are some very difficult choices about things like night classes and year-round high schools.
We have 33.9 percent of the voters to thank for that.
