Suppose you’re a developer.
You’ve been planning a housing project and a golf course for more than a decade. It’s a lucrative project, one that you view as very important to your business. You get the development approved by the local governing agency, and begin making plans to build homes and grade the fairways and greens.
Not long after that approval is granted, you are sued. Opponents of the project don’t believe you have dotted all the environmental I’s and crossed all the planning T’s.
The project is put on hold, while you await the legal outcome.
The case winds its way through the courts, and ultimately, you lose— with, perhaps, some good reason. You are sent back to the drawing board, with instructions from the court that you must better address the project’s impacts on air quality and other issues.
You spend the next seven years revamping the project. You scale back some of the planned residential development, pull out some of the planned commercial space, and reduce the number of oak trees you’ll kill by 25 percent. There are 1,375 oaks on the site, and you plan to remove 146 of them.
You think you have a good plan, one that leaves 250 acres of permanent open space, preserves a little over 89 percent of the oaks on the site and provides two new community amenities: An important new road connection and a tournament-quality golf course that could someday land your community a PGA Tour event— a potential economic development tool of epic proportions.
You feel good about the project. Again.
You get sued. Again.
But this time, you win.
The environmentalists’ lawsuit is dismissed, and the judge agrees that you have adequately addressed the issues at hand. The environmentalists vow to appeal, but for the moment, you have all of the approvals— executive and judicial— that you need to begin developing your property. The challenges to your project have delayed it by approximately seven years, but for the first time, it seems you have all the green lights you need.
What do you do?
Do you wait for your opponents to make their next move, or do you send out the chainsaw crews and start removing oak trees and making ready to grade your site?
The choice seems obvious— and apparently it seemed obvious to The Newhall Land and Farming Co., which started removing oak trees last week from the site of its planned 1, 712-home Westridge development along the west side of Interstate 5. Of the 1,375 oaks on the land, at least 1,229 are being preserved and as many 146 are getting the ax.
And how did Westridge’s foes react?
With anger, of course. They even went so far as to say, “They know we are going to appeal and they went in and cut the trees down,” as if it should be Newhall Land officials’ responsibility to act based on what they think their enemies will do next.
We’re not saying anyone should feel “sorry” for that poor developer, Newhall Land. Sympathy isn’t the issue here. The issue is, did Newhall Land have the right to chop down those trees? Of course it did; it had a court victory and county-approved entitlements in hand. Should anyone have been surprised by the developer’s decision to move forward? Of course not; it’s not Newhall Land’s job to operate its business based on the possibility that someone might appeal a court ruling.
And if anyone says they would have done anything any differently if they were in Newhall Land’s shoes, they’re lying to themselves.
