How much would you be willing to risk on a bet that could pay $143 million? Would you risk $7,000 to $10,000? And what would the odds have to be for you to take the bet?
Those two questions are confronting the William S. Hart Union High School District board tonight, which must decide whether to request a recount in the Measure S school bond election.
If they do request the recount, they are in essence gambling with our money— normally not a good idea when you are responsible for public dollars.
But that’s exactly what they should do.
Since there remains a possibility that Measure S may actually have won, the board in its special meeting tonight should take the plunge, and order a recount.
According to the “official” vote count certified by the Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder ’s office, Measure S carried 66.57 percent of the vote— just shy of the two-thirds majority needed— with 11,359 “yes” votes.
The margin of defeat was a mere 18 votes.
However, for one reason or another, 236 votes were not counted. That could mean some of those ballots were damaged, or had “chads” still attached to the punch-out holes. Such votes, if questioned, would be reviewed by a ruling board.
In the event of a recount, what would that mean for the odds for or against Measure S? It’s difficult to say— but it’s not difficult to imagine a scenario where a recount could affect the outcome of such a close tally.
Estimates of the cost of a recount vary, and it could cost as much as $7,000 to $10,000. That’s probably a risk worth taking: Not only would Measure S provide $52 million in local bond money, it would also make the Hart district eligible for $143 million in state matching funds that will not be given to the district unless it passes a local bond.
That $143 million is the real key: Combined with the Measure S funds, it would enable the Hart district to provide sorely needed renovation of its existing campuses and would also enable the district to build three new high schools and two new junior highs.
Without that money, the school board in the near future will begin seriously considering options like multi-track and split sessions, as well as night classes in local high schools.
It’s obvious that the potential benefits are much greater than the $52 million Measure S would directly generate. This is a case in which a gamble could result not only in a financial windfall, but also in a dramatically superior education environment for every junior high and high school student in this valley.
Yes, it’s a risk— perhaps a loss of $7,000 to $10,000 if Measure S still fails on the recount. And yes, there is a good chance Measure S will still lose. But the potential payoff if it wins is too enormous to ignore. The Hart school board should exhaust all reasonable options if there is even a remote chance Measure S actually passed.
That means rolling the dice tonight, and asking for a recount.
