We shouldn’t have to look at a city’s first major sports championship in 12 years as the impetus for a pair of no-win dilemmas, but that’s exactly what happened after the Los Angeles Lakers won the NBA title on Monday night.
It was a cause for much celebration in the Southland, and much celebration in fact occurred, culminating Wednesday with a downtown victory parade attended peacefully by an estimated 200,000 Angelenos.
It took far fewer than that to cast a temporary pall over the Lakers’ 116-111 win over the Indiana Pacers on Monday night.
A celebratory mob outside Staples Center got a little on the ugly side in the hours after the game, pounding and torching police cars and news vans, smashing windows and looting stores as bonfires were lit in city intersections.
It wasn’t quite a riot. But it was close.
Eleven people were arrested and four police officers were injured in the melee, which diverted media attention from the Lakers’ championship celebration and forced some members of the team to wait around inside Staples Center until law enforcement officials determined it was safe for them to leave.
And therein are the two dilemmas:
When a party goes bad as it did Monday night, how should the media and police handle it? There are problems with each possible course of action.
First, for the media:
How should television news stations handle such a flare-up ? On Monday night, several stations monitored the post-game violence— which was really only perpetrated by a small percentage of the crowd— with cameras rolling live on the ground and via helicopter.
From a traditional journalism standpoint, that was the right thing to do. Their job is to show us newsworthy events, and it is certainly news when a mob gets out of control and damages public and private property.
But there are those who would say the presence of those cameras only encourages the negative behavior, and calls attention to the incident that results in “curiosity seekers” venturing to the area to become involved.
It’s impossible to say whether that would prove true if the cameras were removed from the equation, and we wouldn’t argue that newsgathering organizations should do anything other than cover the news. But there are those out there who would make that argument, and any way you slice it, the electronic media in a case such as this are going to get beat up no matter what they do: They would either be accused of promoting the violence or of shirking their duty to cover the news.
That’s a no-win situation.
Then there’s the police perspective: If you were in charge of the Los Angeles Police Department’s response to the goings-on in downtown Los Angeles Monday night, how would you have handled it?
Would you have charged in with batons swinging and put a forceful and immediate end to the bad behavior? This course of action would have drawn criticism claiming excessive use of force— always a sensitive topic when dealing with any police agency, but especially the LAPD.
Or, would you have adopted a more passive posture, interceding only when it appeared people were in danger of being injured? This course of action would have drawn criticism claiming an insufficient response that allowed lawbreakers to rampage relatively unchecked.
That, too, is a no-win situation, and even as the news was breaking Monday night some television reporters questioned the LAPD’s lack of force in breaking up the melee.
It’s unfortunate that these dilemmas came to the fore in the midst of an otherwise joyous moment— one in which a championship-starved Los Angeles finally tasted the fruits of professional sports victory.
