The silence out of Porta Bella attorney Wayne Souza was deafening this week when The Signal’s reporters tried to contact him about an insurance company lawsuit. It is becoming increasingly evident that the contaminated land in the middle of Santa Clarita can and probably will be cleaned up without the city having to approve a single home.
On Feb. 14, the property owner, Santa Clarita LLC, signed a binding agreement with the state, accepting responsibility for cleaning the soil and groundwater regardless of whether it builds anything.
In the 1980s the state got a similar court order against the former property owner, Whittaker Corp., giving that company “ cradle-to-grave ” responsibility for the cleanup. As far as the state government and the courts are concerned, the current and former property owners must clean the property.
How are they supposed to pay for that cleanup, if Santa Clarita LLC has only $3 million available to it and the cleanup might cost $100 million or more?
Well, last year the Castaic Lake Water Agency and three local water retailers filed suit to force the insurance companies to fulfill their obligation to pay for repairing environmental damage.
There is both current and “historic” insurance on the property. For instance, Santa Clarita LLC has an insurance policy covering cleanup costs up to $75 million (but not the first $44 million). Given the water purveyors’ lawsuit, Santa Clarita LLC’s insurance company has filed suit against the property owner, trying to get out of paying.
But Whittaker and its predecessor, Bermite Powder Co., had insurance, and those policies put the carriers on the hook for cleanup costs. The water purveyors filed their lawsuit primarily to ferret out the historic insurance and force activation of the polluters’ coverage.
So, what is all this we’re hearing about “phased” development?
It’s simply a property owner who wants everyone to believe it must start building 2,911 homes and various commercial buildings if it is to generate enough money to clean the property.
That much may be true: If Porta Bella couldn’t be cleaned without the property owner borrowing money, Santa Clarita LLC would probably need to build in phases. But the property will be cleaned without the owner borrowing money. Under its Feb. 14 agreement with the state, Santa Clarita LLC is required to “conduct” the cleanup. The old insurance companies will have to pony up the cash, once the water purveyors’ lawsuit roots them out.
In 1995 the city of Santa Clarita signed a development agreement with the property owner, agreeing to let it build those 2,911 homes once the entire site has been cleaned. An agreement is an agreement, and Santa Clarita LLC hasn’t lived up to its end of the bargain.
The agreement requires Santa Clarita LLC to cover the city under its insurance policy if it has one. Santa Clarita LLC does have liability insurance— and has had, since Dec. 30, 1998— and it did not cover the city. It still doesn’t. Even if Santa Clarita LLC were to add the city as an “additional insured” now, it would be too late. For two and a half years Santa Clarita LLC has violated the agreement, exposing the city to liability.
The agreement assigns certain legal responsibilities to the city with respect to the Porta Bella property. Anyone who wanted to sue over environmental damage since Dec. 30, 1998— say, a water company with a polluted well— could have sued the property owner and the city. The property owner would have been covered, and the city wouldn’t have been— at least, not under the property owner’s policy, as required.
You could drive a truck through the hole that was carved into the agreement when Santa Clarita LLC failed to cover the city, then refused to comply with the city attorney’s repeated requests to show him the policy.
This cannot be dismissed as simple neglect. It is outrageous. The City Council should immediately declare Santa Clarita LLC in default under the development agreement, step aside so the court system can weed out the insurance companies, and let the state do its job in forcing the cleanup.
