The Santa Clarita City Council made two good moves Tuesday night on the trash front. They approved Councilman Cameron Smyth’s call to track the city’s trash franchise fees, and they endorsed his recommendation for the council to draft the scope of the city’s upcoming trash audit.
‘Smyth was a lone wolf earlier this year when he tried to convince his fellow council members first to eliminate, then to reduce, the city’s trash franchise fees— and that’s unfortunate.’
Smyth was a lone wolf earlier this year when he tried to convince his fellow council members first to eliminate, then to reduce, the city’s trash franchise fees— and that’s unfortunate. The city takes 10 percent off the top of every residential and commercial trash bill in the form of a hidden tax that really is hidden: Under their franchise agreements, the city’s three waste haulers aren’t allowed to disclose the city’s cut to their customers.
The real trouble with the franchise fee is that it goes into the general fund instead of a special fund designed to pay trash-related expenses, such the city’s cost of administering the contracts and fixing streets damaged by trash trucks. It is difficult to know if the fees, which now top $1.3 million a year, are really being put to their intended use.
City Finance Director Steve Stark said the city has tracked how much has come in, but it hasn’t previously tracked where the money has gone. He thinks it won’t be that hard to do. It should have been done all along.
More importantly still, the council backed Smyth’s motion to name himself and Mayor Laurene Weste to a council subcommittee that will draft a scoping plan for an audit of the city’s solid waste franchises.
Numerous questions have been raised about the way city staff members have handled those franchises, ever since The Signal learned the city was reportedly sending more trash to landfills than state law allows. In the interim it has come to light that customer trash fees were miscalculated in 1996, and they would be lower still if recalculated today. Instead those high rates would be locked in until 2006 if the city approves new trash contracts that staff members said were the best deal they could negotiate.
Residents and businesses would have been better served if the City Council had opened the franchises to competitive bids. They didn’t, and they even rejected an offer from one of the existing haulers to lower consumer prices by 19 percent in exchange for a bigger piece of the trash-hauling pie.
It smells fishy, but after all, this is the trash business. The council needs to “scope” an audit that will examine every scrap of pertinent paperwork— if it still exists— and determine who promised what to whom.
A normal audit can’t do that. A normal audit simply looks to see that standard accounting practices were followed. What’s needed is a forensic audit, which will uncover intentional wrongdoing if there was any. It’s an audit that can stand up in court and can be conducted by a specialized accounting firm, police agency or other type of investigative agency.
The new subcommittee of Smyth and Weste will need to explore all the options and report back to the full council with a recommendation that will follow the money trail, wherever it may lead.
