Permission to advertise.
‘The sign, to be erected on private property at private expense and in compliance with the city’s sign law, only needs one thing: Permission to advertise.’
That’s what The Newhall Land and Farming Co. is seeking when it goes before the Santa Clarita Planning Commission tonight— and from a First Amendment, freedom of speech perspective, it seems like it should be a slam dunk.
Newhall Land is asking the city to allow the developer to build a “freeway commercial sign” on Newhall Land’s property along Interstate 5, about 750 feet north of Valencia Boulevard.
The sign would be used to promote the Valencia Town Center mall, Town Center Drive, the Hyatt Valencia hotel, the Santa Clarita Auto Mall and the city of Santa Clarita.
The sign would include an illuminated message board that would display messages to I-5 motorists in the hopes of generating interest in the city and local businesses.
The proposal, ironically, sounds similar to the message board sign at the Santa Clarita Athletic Club, off of Calgrove Boulevard. The athletic club’s sign is undergoing a redesign as a result of the city’s attempts over the past year to force its removal. The athletic club’s sign, which predates the city sign ordinance, never should have been an issue. The club should be allowed to make the decision on whether to keep its sign or go with a revised design.
Newhall Land’s sign, however, is a separate matter.
As proposed, the sign would comply with the city sign ordinance’s restrictions on sign height and size. While some residents may bristle at the notion of an illuminated message board, the sign’s design is intended to direct the messages to the intended audience— freeway motorists— without having the illumination spill over into nearby neighborhoods.
And the sign could have major economic benefits.
For example, the auto mall on Creekside Road generates an estimated $800 million in sales annually, bringing in approximately $4.1 million in sales tax revenue to the city.
If the sign is approved, the auto dealers expect that local sales tax figure to jump by as much as $800,000 per year, bringing the city’s cut from local auto sales nearly to the $5 million mark.
Even if you choose a more conservative number than the auto dealers’ estimate of a 20-percent boost in business as a result of the sign, the potential benefits to the local economy are significant. The sign would not only promote the city of Santa Clarita— which would be allocated 20 percent of the message board time— but would also promote businesses, like the mall complex and the Hyatt, that can derive customers from freeway traffic and non-residents but do not have freeway visibility of their own.
The sign, to be erected on private property at private expense and in compliance with the city’s sign law, only needs one thing: Permission to advertise.
Considering the fact that the proposed message board complies with the city’s sign regulations, that permission ought to be granted.
