And then there were three.
When our city’s elected leaders came around to the notion that questions about the local trash situation warranted an audit, those close to the situation indicated that a “Big 5” auditing firm should be brought in to do the work, in order to ensure the most credible examination possible.
That belief is correct, and remains correct even on the heels of news that one of the Big 5 has agreed to pay $7 million in federal penalties for filing false audits of Waste Management Inc.
It was announced Tuesday that Arthur Andersen LLP and four of its partners agreed to the fines in relation to a case in which they were accused of overstating Waste Management’s profits by more than $1 billion, making the company more attractive to investors.
As it happens, Waste Management controls 85 percent of the city’s residential trash service: It is the parent company of two of the three local haulers, Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal.
It’s worth noting that the Arthur Andersen case is related to audits performed in the mid-1990s , before Waste Management purchased the local companies, and this particular story does not implicate the local companies in any wrongdoing.
However, Councilman Cameron Smyth was correct Tuesday when he responded to the Arthur Andersen story, saying, “I want to make sure that we don’t use a firm that has relationships with the haulers.”
That’s a good point, and even without the $7 million in federal penalties, the city would be well-advised to steer clear of Arthur Andersen, or any other auditor that has a pre-existing relationship with the haulers in question. That, then, would also seem to exclude PricewaterhouseCoopers, which has an account with Republic Services, parent of the local hauler, Atlas Disposal.
Further, the council must go into the audit with the awareness that, as exemplified by the Arthur Andersen case, even the results of a “Big 5” audit can be called into question.
It’s all a part of what should be an effort by the City Council to ensure that the audit is as independent as possible, and to ensure that whatever auditing firm is chosen is beholden not to the haulers or to the city staff, but directly to the City Council and the taxpayers. The audit should address serious questions about local trash rates, waste diversion numbers and the city staff’s handling of the trash situation. This can best be accomplished if the auditing firm that is chosen has no link to the trash haulers— and is not at all under the impression that it is reporting to the city staff.
It seems, then, to leave three of the Big 5 in the running: KPMG Consulting, Ernst & Young and Deloitte & Touche.
Smyth said he hopes to have a recommendation on the audit for the full council to consider on June 26. Hopefully, that discussion will bring the council a step closer to commissioning an audit by one of the “big three.”
