As flip-flops go, this one wasn't anything to flip out over: The City Council on Tuesday came to its senses and reworded its position on the proposed reduction or repeal of the state's car tax.
A couple of weeks ago, the council voted to oppose the proposed car tax repeal unless cities were given a guarantee that their flow of car tax funds would not be cut off.
In contrast, other cities like Lancaster vote to favor the car tax repeal, provided their funding levels would be guaranteed to remain the same.
In one sense, the motions were the same: Both Lancaster and Santa Clarita had made the preservation of the cities' state revenue stream a condition of their endorsement of the car tax repeal.
But there was an important difference: Lancaster said, "We will support it if ..."
Santa Clarita said, "We will oppose it unless ..."
Semantics? Yes. But important semantics nonetheless.
By changing its vote from a statement of opposition to a statement of support -- while preserving the language that calls for cities to be kept whole -- Êthe city can now be added to the growing list of supporters for the tax cut, lending more ammunition to legislators like Assemblyman George Runner, R-Lancaster.
Runner, who represents most of the Santa Clarita Valley, is one of the most ardent advocates of the car tax repeal, which is a sure-fire hit with many Californians. Currently, the average car owner's annual tax, paid with auto registration, is approximately $185. Individuals who own new cars, and have already paid sales taxes or lease taxes, routinely pay an annual car tax of more than $300.
The bulk of the tax is funneled to cities within the state, so the proposed repeal has understandably raised a few eyebrows at city halls up and down the state. For example, the city of Santa Clarita is receiving approximately $5.8 million in car tax revenue for the 1997-98 fiscal year.
However, the car tax proposals that are on the table in Sacramento call for a constitutional amendment to guarantee that the cities' car tax funding will be replaced by state general fund revenue. Considering the fact that the state has an estimated $4.4 billion surplus, there's no time like the present to give the taxpayers a little bit of their hard-earned money back. The alternative, of course, is for the government to simply spend more money -- Êand no one in their right mind would argue in favor of that.
Hence, it's gratifying to see the City Council shift its position on the car tax -- thanks, obviously, to some not-so-subtle lobbying by legislators and their representatives. Mayor Jan Heidt cast the lone dissenting vote, and seemed to be more preoccupied with partisan issues of who lobbied who than she was with what's right for taxpayers.
Fortunately, the majority of the council saw it differently, and revised its position to reflect not only a concern for the city's revenue stream, but also a concern for taxpayers' revenue stream.
