The public spoke and the city listened: Responding to numerous requests from residents to expand the collection of recyclables, the city and the local trash companies with which it franchises agreed last year to increase service from bi-weekly to weekly. The City Council approved the deal in January, and starting July 1, you'll see recycling trucks in your neighborhood more frequently.
The improved service is a welcome change in a city that pays more for trash disposal than other similar size cities, yet hasn't received the same amount of recycling service. That's not to say, of course, there won't be a rate increase with this latest service increase.
Negotiations between the city and the trash haulers are expected sometime later this year to determine how the added service has affected costs and if a price hike is necessary. If collection prices go up, residents won't see the bump on their bills until next year, or, if a rate hike is approved after Jan. 1, 1999, until 2000.
Though city officials and trash providers aren't ready to say if collection costs will increase, we're ready to question if they should.
Research by The Signal last year showed that Santa Clarita residents pay 31 percent more on average for their trash service than those living in several comparably sized Southland cities. The catch is, you are paying more, but getting less recycling service: bi-weekly pickups instead of weekly.
Palmdale and Lancaster pay nearly $7 less than Santa Clarita, but they get weekly recycling. Palmdale's service goes one better. Residents throw all their garbage in one container, and the trash carrier gleans the recyclables at a materials recovery facility.
In their defense, local trash haulers said many factors go into deciding service costs, including labor, fuel, truck maintenance, landfill fees and the 10 percent the city collects from all revenues generated by trash pickup. Make no mistake: That 10 percent franchise fee is a thinly veiled local tax on your trash. Assuming trash haulers are collecting a reasonable profit margin rather than an excessive one, that 10 percent franchise fee looks like a wonderful place to start cutting residents' costs.
The city is also at a disadvantage because it does not own its own dump and is subject to fluctuating fees at local landfills.
As the summer rolls on and weekly service starts, the question will arise: "Can residents get more without paying more?" The city and its trash haulers say they will have an answer in coming months.
If the answer is yes, and the service increase will not spark a rate increase, it will prove what some have long suspected: Residents were not getting their money's worth. They were paying more and getting less.
If the answer is no, that residents can't get more without paying more, then there should be some very good reasons why, especially when Santa Claritans are already paying more than their counterparts in neighboring valleys.
This wait-and-see approach to answer the rate increase question raises other questions. Calculating added costs doesn't seem too difficult when present costs are well-established. So why wait? Is it a stalling tactic? Do the powers that be hope that by waiting they can raise rates without a fuss? If that's the case, we will speak and hopefully the city will listen.
While we wait for an answer, we'll enjoy the new weekly recycling -- and hope it won't end up costing more than it should.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
