Ironically enough, we have chosen Father's Day to discuss parental responsibility. And with all due respect to the many terrific Dads -- and Moms -- out there, it's a timely topic.
Concern about juvenile crime is ever-increasing, and while Santa Clarita remains one of the safest cities in the land, the news on a regional and national level is often replete with tales of youthful perpetrators.
As it is on most such issues, the city of Santa Clarita is taking, to use the bureaucrats' term, a proactive approach on youth crime.
The city has a variety of programs and services aimed at keeping kids on the straight and narrow, and most of these efforts are both well-intentioned and successful.
But there's one well-intentioned movement afoot that could get the city into some sticky situations.
Santa Clarita is pondering the possibility of implementing a "parental responsibility ordinance," a measure that would be aimed at encouraging parents to take an active role in the supervision of their youngsters and hold parents accountable for the actions of their progeny.
Therein lies the potential danger for the city: The ordinance would hold one individual accountable for the actions of another.
Would that be unconstitutional?
It's at least subject to debate. On one hand, you could argue that parents are legally responsible for the health, safety and welfare of their children until they turn 18, so it's not much of a stretch to say a penalty can be imposed on a parent if the child commits a crime.
But on the other hand, it's also easy to argue that a parent's right to due process would be infringed upon if the parent is penalized for the actions of another human being, even if that human being is one's child.
In fact, City Attorney Carl Newton tells us, a California Supreme Court ruling has found that a city could be open to lawsuits if criminal infractions are imposed in such cases, since a parent's right to due process would be compromised.
As a result, Newton has recommended that, rather than criminal penalties, any parental responsibility ordinance should instead make it a civil matter, to be enforced by the city instead of the Sheriff's Department.
Even then, there's some question over whether "penalizing" parents is the way to go. Try as they might, some parents are simply saddled with a child who will not behave. In such instances, criminal prosecution and incarceration of the child may be the only option.
Plus, Santa Clarita is already on the right track in so many areas. If the city stays the course when it comes to putting forth the right educational and community activity programs, for adults and youths alike, it will achieve desired results.
The city is expected to revisit the issue this summer, and it appears as if some city leaders may be bent on making it a criminal matter, regardless of the city attorney's advice.
Under the original plan, criminal penalties would be imposed upon parents of youth criminals, starting with parenting classes and, upon multiple violations, progressing to fines and community service.
It doesn't take a legal expert to recognize that's risky ground, and as good as the city's intentions are, it ought to look very carefully before leaping into such a proposition -- and most likely shouldn't jump at all.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
