Taking your lumps comes with the territory when you’re the community newspaper: When you dish out your opinion on local issues via editorials and opinion columns, you had better be prepared to take, and publish, criticism from those who disagree with you.
That exchange of ideas, uncomfortably heated as it may be, is a big part of a community paper’s function. A newspaper should encourage healthy debate about what’s best for the community, and on its editorial pages should strive to promote the community’s best interests.
That’s our goal here.
With that in mind, we’d like to reiterate some of our long-standing positions on one of the most controversial issues facing the Santa Clarita Valley: Growth. It’s a topic that receives a great deal of attention in community meetings, letters to The Signal and in that sparkplug of community forums, Tell It to The Signal .
In each of these venues, it seems there are a few individuals who choose to portray The Signal’s position on growth to be “whatever Newhall Land wants,” or something akin to, “Rape the land, tear down all the hillsides and to hell with the environment, our roads and our schools, just build more homes.”
That, for the record, is not the case. Not even close. Some of the aforementioned individuals intentionally misrepresent The Signal’s growth position for their own political gain.
If one had to attach a “label” to this newspaper’s position on growth, we’d prefer something like, “ pro-responsible growth.” Our definition of “responsible” includes some philosophies consistent with those in the development industry, and some philosophies that are not.
We’ll start with the former: We believe in the basic rights of a land owner to develop that land, to the extent that it does not unduly infringe upon the rights of others to use and enjoy their property. This is a difficult balance, and the rights of existing residents often conflict with the rights of individuals who wish to build. But in general, we believe free market principles should guide the evolution of a developing community.
Further, we believe the best interests of the SCV are served by development that brings new amenities, economic growth and infrastructure improvements. As it stands, the valley suffers from a severe infrastructure deficit due to years of poorly planned growth, especially in areas where there was no master plan and communities were built in hodgepodge fashion by various developers.
Problem is, you can’t close that infrastructure gap by “making the developers pay” unless you in turn allow them to build new neighborhoods. Thus, in order to gain the infrastructure and amenities most Santa Claritans want and need, we must accommodate a certain amount of construction— with, of course, reasonable limits on volume and density.
Hopefully, that new construction will also translate into success for local merchants and companies; as they prosper, so will the residents of our community.
Now to the flip side: We firmly believe development should pay its own way. Does a new housing tract add traffic to our already overburdened streets and freeways? If so, it must be accompanied by funds for highway improvements and new road construction.
Further, is the new residential community balanced with sufficient commercial development? What about job opportunities that might help alleviate the commuter crush? Is it planned with due care to the environment, and resources like the Santa Clara River?
And finally, perhaps most importantly, what about the schools? This is an area in which The Newhall Land and Farming Co., the valley’s largest developer, has taken a great deal of heat— yet has struck deals with local school districts to ensure that its new communities will have the schools they need.
However, there is one clear area in which we sharply disagree with Newhall Land: The developer has long advocated legislation to cap a developer’s “share” of the cost of a new school, with state tax funds to pick up the rest of the tab.
We disagree with this principle. Developers’ “share” of new school construction necessitated by growth ought to be 100 percent, with no portion being picked up by taxpayers. If, for example, a new development generates need for one new elementary school, the developer ought to fully fund the construction of one new elementary school. This formula ought to be prorated for developments that generate less— or more— need, and the same principle should be applied to junior and senior high schools.
That, in an obviously abbreviated nutshell, is this paper’s position on growth— we advocate well-planned , reasonable growth that is controlled and managed in a manner that allows for desirable amenities, economic growth and infrastructure improvements throughout all of the Santa Clarita Valley’s communities.
As always, we will welcome and publish the views of our readers. And, as always, we will openly take our lumps from those who disagree.
