The five fiefdoms have outlived their usefulness as a system of local government representation in Los Angeles County.
The county is too vast, too populated, for a five-member Board of Supervisors to be an effective means of “local” governance, regardless of how well-intentioned or hard-working any one supervisor may be.
That’s why Senate Majority Leader Richard G. Polanco, D-Los Angeles, has authored Senate Constitutional Amendment 7. The legislation— which would also need voter approval— would require a minimum of nine supervisors in any county with a population exceeding 5 million.
That may sound generic, and technically it is; but SCA 7 really only applies to Los Angeles County, by far the state’s most populous.
In response to Polanco’s effort to address the issue on a statewide level, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors is moving to place the matter on the November county ballot.
Make no mistake: Although county supervisors are correct in asserting that their move would allow county residents to make a county-level decision, their purpose is to take the matter out of the hands of the state’s voters, who would likely approve SCA 7.
Regardless of which route it takes, if SCA 7 or a facsimile is enacted, the nine districts in Los Angeles County would still be vast territories in terms of population and geography.
For example, the new Fifth District would consist of Santa Clarita, Lancaster, Palmdale, Agoura Hills, Calabasas, Hidden Hills, Malibu and Westlake Village, plus unincorporated areas such as Val Verde. Imagine trying to represent all of those communities well, and to take all of their diverse interests into account as you go about the business of running a county.
It’s a tall order, and the order is even taller when only five supervisors handle a county of 5 million-plus .
The measure, of course, isn’t popular in all circles; the SCV’s own Supervisor Mike Antonovich argues that it will add new government costs to staff nine supervisors’ offices instead of five.
Perhaps that’s true— and a board expansion, no doubt, would diminish the power base of the five people who currently enjoy positions on the Board of Supervisors.
But as Polanco’s office points out, this legislation would improve residents’ ability to gain access to their county government, and would enable each community to have a stronger influence on the selection of their supervisor.
Also, Assemblyman George Runner— a Lancaster Republican who represents most of the SCV— notes that Los Angeles County is unique in its size, and thus should be dealt with uniquely to bring down the number of constituents each supervisor has.
That gets to the heart of the matter: A county government is supposed to be just the second level on the local-regional-state-federal government food chain. With each supervisor representing more than a million people, it’s impossible for that representation to be as “local” as it is supposed to be.
