As if there weren’t enough reasons to obliterate the Hidden Valley barricade, another emerged this week:
The city’s own attorney says it may be illegal.
In a confidential letter to the City Council in 1998, City Attorney Carl Newton told the council that there are legal problems with the barricade, which allows Hidden Valley residents exclusive access to a link between Valley Street and Calgrove Boulevard.
And further, closing off the link to everyone could get complicated.
Newton’s letter—Êobtained by The Signal this week from a non-city source— says in part that “the city would place itself in a tenuous legal position if it were to place a permanent barricade between Calgrove Boulevard and Valley Street.”
Newton’s letter said a better option would be for the city to shut down the link with cul de sacs. In other words, from a legal standpoint the city is in the best shape if it allows access either to everyone or no one. Allowing one group of residents exclusive access to a public street link that shows up on the city’s General Plan could land Santa Clarita in hot water.
Further, in order to close off the link with cul-de-sacs — an option currently being studied by the city— the City Council would have to rule that the Calgrove-Valley link is no longer a needed part of the local traffic circulation plan. That’s a tough sell.
The Valley-Calgrove gate has been the subject of much local controversy over the past several years. The situation was created in the 1980s as Hidden Valley was developed, and in response to concern from existing residents, Los Angeles County granted Hidden Valley residents exclusive access.
Many Valley Street residents fear that, if the connection were opened to all traffic, then their neighborhood tranquility would be spoiled by too many cars speeding down the residential link. Opponents of the gate say it’s wrong to shut off a perfectly good road link that could provide many Newhall residents an easier means of gaining access to Interstate 5 via Calgrove Boulevard.
Given Newton’s 1998 advice regarding a barrier that grants some residents exclusive access— such as that enjoyed by Hidden Valley residents now— it appears the city only has two legitimate options: Open the link to everyone, or seal it off with cul-de-sacs .
The latter option, of course, would give Valley Street residents peace of mind. A verdict on the cul de sac option is expected in the coming months, as the city is soon expected to complete an environmental study on the proposal.
But it wouldn’t bring the greatest good to the greatest number of city residents, and the city would be hard-pressed to make a convincing case that the Valley-Calgrove link should be wiped off the General Plan.
The Santa Clarita Valley needs more roads, not fewer. It needs to increase the options for motorists, not decrease them.
The ideal solution would be to banish the barrier, open the road to everyone and to take whatever “traffic calming” measures are necessary to ensure a safe rate of traffic flow on Valley Street.
Hopefully, the city will take all of these factors— and the city attorney’s own advice— into account when deciding the fate of the Valley-Calgrove connection.
