No. That was the brunt of the message the City Council sent with its 5-0 vote Tuesday rejecting a proposal to replace an independent, community-based committee that’s monitoring the cleanup of the contaminated Porta Bella property in the middle of the city.
Staff had recommended creating a new, city-controlled task force to monitor the cleanup, but the council said no, instead deciding to support the existing, independent group.
The council also decided to take up the issue of “phasing” when it reconvenes after its summer break, apparently with the intent of rejecting that idea, too.
The developer wants to be able to clean and sell the property in phases, because it says that otherwise, it can’t afford to rid the land of 275 different contaminants left behind after decades of munitions manufacturing.
But the property owner knew full well when it bought the land that it was bound to the terms of a 1995 agreement with the city, prohibiting it from building even one home until the entire site was cleaned to the specifications of state environmental officials.
If they want to back out of that agreement, that’s just too bad. The city can’t afford the liability if it allows homes to be built and something blows up, or if the pollution maims or kills Porta Bella children.
It’s not like the property won’t be cleaned up, regardless of whether homes are built. A lawsuit has already been filed to force the activation of insurance policies that do exist, covering cleanup of the contamination.
Moreover, the property owner hasn’t given the city any good reason to want to bend the rules. The developer broke the terms of its own agreement with the city by failing to provide requested insurance documentation, and has failed to indemnify the city against liability as called for in the agreement.
There has been a lot of back-room politicking in the two and a half years since the current owner bought the property. The community hasn’t been privy to much of it until recently, but what we do know is that there is a different City Council majority today— a more reasoned and cautious one, when it comes to Porta Bella.
Two years ago the council, which included Jill Klajic and Jan Heidt, agreed— in a non-binding way— to try to enable the developer to building in phases. Today Klajic and Heidt are no longer on the council; they’ve been replaced by Cameron Smyth and Bob Kellar, who are dealing with a company that has amassed a 2 1/ 2-year track record of broken promises.
It’s time now for the council to un-mix any messages that may have been sent in the past, and stand firm in saying no to jeopardizing the city’s health and welfare by allowing any development before the entire site is clean.
