The problems are real, and Councilman Frank Ferry’s intentions may be good. However, his proposed growth management initiative is the wrong approach, for several reasons.
Ferry is correct when he asserts that the city of Santa Clarita faces a daunting deficit when it comes to infrastructure. We need somewhere around 16 to 18 new schools. We are 550 acres short on park space. And we need a variety of new roads, some of which are slated to be built over the next 10 years.
It is during that 10-year period that Ferry proposes to let the infrastructure “catch up” by limiting new home approvals in the city: He has put forth a ballot initiative that, if approved by voters in April, would set a 3, 000-unit cap on new homes that could be approved by the city in the ensuing decade.
It will almost certainly be attractive to a large number of voters who are disenchanted with the local population boom, and if one of Ferry’s goals is to ride the crest of his initiative to a popular re-election victory next year, it may well work. Ferry’s initiative is likely to stir anti-growth sentiments among a public made restless by years of inadequate planning for things like schools and roads.
Ferry speaks passionately about the issues that have prompted him to propose this measure, and the passion does seem sincere. And whatever the outcome, you have to give him credit: Long viewed as a councilman who supported development— and vice versa—ÊFerry risks losing a major support base by coming out as a growth cap advocate. Certainly, Ferry’s long-time supporters at The Newhall Land and Farming Co. and in the local business community can’t be very happy with his proposal.
Ironically, Ferry’s initiative has a lower cap than the 1991 initiative that was opposed by most of Ferry’s political backers and was defeated by voters. That plan would have set an annual cap of 476 new homes in the city.
Ferry plans to bring his initiative to his colleagues on the City Council in August, seeking approval to begin the process of placing the initiative on April’s ballot. If the council declines, Ferry says he would pursue the alternative: A petition drive.
What’s unfortunate is that the initiative will be popular with many voters who won’t recognize its real impacts.
First and foremost, a 3, 000-unit cap within city limits really won’t solve much of anything. In raw numbers, it actually pretty closely resembles the status quo: In the past 10 years, approximately 4,250 homes have been built within the city, and the median number in a given year is 299.
Further, the initiative will not build one more school or road, and it will in all likelihood diminish Santa Clarita’s influence on the real growth battleground, outside the city’s borders.
As Ferry correctly notes, the city’s ability to influence growth in unincorporated Los Angeles County territory has been limited because the county Local Agency Formation Commission has thrice rejected Santa Clarita’s bid for a “sphere of influence” west of Interstate 5 and east of state Route 14. The sphere would have given the city an official seat at the table— and the right to have its input considered— as the county considers development outside the city.
Ferry’s proposed initiative does nothing to alleviate that, and may in fact worsen the problem.
In the current scenario, if a developer wants to build on land adjacent to the city, the builder might approach the city about the possibility of an annexation— giving the city an opportunity to help shape the project before it is built. With Ferry’s growth cap, those developers most likely would not bother with the city, and would stick with the county approval process, without city influence.
And, the majority of the Santa Clarita Valley’s growth would be unchecked by the 3, 000-unit cap, because most of the undeveloped land is within the jurisdiction of the county, not the city.
Finally, there is a very real property rights issue in play.
Like it or not, land owners have rights to develop their property. It is the responsibility of local government to ensure that development does not cause undue burdens on existing residents— for example, by adding vehicle trips without building sufficient roads, or by adding students without sufficient schools.
The county in particular has done a poor job in the past two decades of providing for infrastructure, and the state and its voters have created a situation in which developers are not held wholly accountable for construction of new schools necessitated by growth. Those factors have led us to the situation we face now. However, that does not strip land owners of their rights.
That’s why a numeric cap is wrong in principle: If you happen to be a property owner and your project starts with unit No. 3,001 under the Ferry cap, your project is dead— even if it brings forth major infrastructure improvements. The cap is inherently unfair, and may be viewed as a “taking” of property rights.
We realize this will not be a popular view, because many people will see a numeric cap as a quick, easy solution.
In reality, it will not solve anything.
