The 29-year-old woman reported a horrible crime:
‘Too often, all of us... become jaded about such matters because it seems as if the majority of suspects who are arrested later turn out to be guilty of some crime or another. But we also must not allow ourselves to forget that some of them are not.’
She said the trucker, whose rig bore Las Vegas plates, pulled her into his truck in a shopping center parking lot, late at night, raped her and then abandoned her at a nearby gas station.
It’s a frightful tale, one that evokes anger from those who hear it. One immediately feels contempt for the suspect, mentally classifying him among the lowest of society’s dregs.
The trucker was arrested, and there were newspaper accounts of the case, complete with the name of the suspect but, as usually is the case, without the name of the alleged victim.
One major problem:
A few days after reporting the crime, the woman admits to the police that she made the whole thing up. There was no rape, just some consensual “ hanky-panky ,” as a sheriff’s deputy put it, and the “crime” was reported as an act of spite because the trucker reneged on his promise to take the woman to Las Vegas.
Deputies had become suspicious of the woman’s story after she initially reported it, because inconsistencies seemed to surface. Later, they would discover that the woman, according to her parents, suffers from mental and physical problems that may have contributed to the fabrication.
We recount this story here, if nothing else, to illustrate a few truths about our system of justice and about our system of covering the news.
First of all, this tale— which transpired over the past week right here in the Santa Clarita Valley— is illustrative of the importance of the presumption of innocence.
Too often, all of us, from newspaper reporters and editors to anyone who reads crime stories in the newspaper, become jaded about such matters because it seems as if the majority of suspects who are arrested later turn out to be guilty of some crime or another.
But we also must not allow ourselves to forget that some of them are not.
It puts newspapers and other media into a difficult position: A big part of our job is to monitor the actions of government agencies, including police, and to report on their actions as they occur. It’s difficult to report on crimes without having readers form their own opinions about guilt or innocence, but the media can’t be put in the position of waiting until all cases play themselves out in court, because that would constitute an abdication of our duty to report the news, to the best of our abilities, as it happens.
In this case, the local police were also doing their job: They received a report of a rape and they took a suspect into custody. Fortunately, they flushed out the truth before the case progressed very far.
Of course, that may be of little consolation to the trucker, who was held in custody while sheriff’s deputies sorted out the situation, and whose name was made known publicly as that of a suspected rapist.
Additionally, this case is illustrative of the fact that every reported rape has at least two potential victims.
There is, of course, the obvious. Rape is a horrible, violent crime that causes much damage, emotionally and physically. There remains a perceived stigma about being a rape victim— which is unfortunate, because a rape victim has done nothing wrong— and we in the media tend to play into it by refraining from naming the victim in accounts of alleged rapes, even though we name the victims of other types of crimes. You won’t see the name of a rape victim in very many media outlets, including this one, and that is not likely to change any time soon.
The situation becomes different, of course, when we find out that the suspect was actually innocent. Then, you won’t see any media outlets hesitating to name the person who falsely accused another of rape.
At that point, the tables have actually turned, and the “suspect” is the real victim. In this case, the Las Vegas trucker was victimized by a false report, and no doubt feels a certain amount of anger at the system and the fact that members of the public became aware that he was accused of a heinous crime.
Both systems are imperfect: Our justice system sometimes arrests, and maybe even convicts, innocent parties, and our free press sometimes reports the existence of crime charges that later prove to be false.
But they are what we have, and even considering the flaws, they are about the best available:
A system of criminal justice in which the burden of proof is on the state and the suspect is— at least in court— presumed innocent, and a free press that monitors that system and tells you about its machinations, warts and all.
