Whose interests are you protecting?
Those of the taxpayers? City employees? Trash haulers? Political friends?
Each member of the Santa Clarita City Council ought to ask himself or herself that question— and answer it honestly— before voting Tuesday on the proposed scope of the upcoming audit of the city’s trash hauling franchises.
We should all hope “taxpayers” is at the top of all five council members’ lists, and we should all give Councilman Cameron Smyth credit for holding his council colleagues’ feet to the fire.
“All I want is the truth,” Smyth told The Signal this week, positioning himself as the taxpayers’ champion in what has become a battle over whether the council should ask all of the pointed, pertinent questions or back off on several key items to appease certain interests.
Smyth plans to bring the audit scope back to the council and get clarification on exactly what the audit will do. If necessary, Smyth says, he’ll ask for an item-by-item , up-or-down vote on which questions the audit should ask. Smyth, the council’s youngest member, seems to be growing nerve beyond his years. And we couldn’t be happier to see it.
At issue is the exact level of depth to be reached by the audit, which has been prompted by a series of questions about trash fees and whether the city, through its contracts with three local haulers, is meeting state waste diversion requirements. Further questions exist about whether the city staff has properly handled those contracts. Certainly the council has never held anyone accountable for those contracts, having never gone out to bid or invoked its auditing powers under the contracts, until now.
The city needs a forensic audit to get to the bottom of these questions.
The haulers have operated under the franchise agreements since 1991, when all three were locally owned. They have since come under ownership of national companies: Santa Clarita Disposal and Blue Barrel are owned by trash giant Waste Management Inc., and Atlas Disposal is owned by an arm of Wayne Huizenga’s financial empire.
One of those ownership changes is among the disputed audit items on the agenda for Tuesday.
Santa Clarita Disposal was locally owned by Steve Arklin until 1998. Councilman Bob Kellar— who acknolwedges that Arklin is a friend of his, but says that is not a factor in his recommendation— says Santa Clarita Disposal should be excluded from the audit for the period prior to 1998, since Arklin is no longer officially doing business with the city. Kellar, a real estate agent, has also had a past business relationship with Arklin, who is a friend of City Manager George Caravalho.
For starters, the audit should begin in 1991, not 1996, because that’s when the contracts— and their problems— were initiated. Yes, it will cost more to audit those additional years, but if the council is truly interested in clearing the air, that’s exactly what it will do. And even if one accepts the notion that the council will order the audit to start in 1996 because that’s when new rates were set and changes made to the contracts, then it only stands to reason that all of the haulers at that time should be included.
There is no valid reason, in the taxpayers’ interests, to exclude Santa Clarita Disposal for the period of Arklin’s ownership. It may be a hassle for those who have to participate in and cooperate with the audit— and Arklin’s friends at City Hall may want to spare him the headache— but it’s important that this audit answer all of the very valid questions about just how the trash situation came to be, and by how many millions taxpayers have been overcharged.
Also among the disputed items are questions on haulers’ charitable contributions and entertainment expenses incurred when courting city officials.
Even Smyth concedes to let the charitable contributions question slide. We understand the logic: Blue Barrel in particular has been very generous to local organizations, and no one wants to see a chilling effect on charitable giving. Whatever the audit’s outcome, there’s no disputing that Blue Barrel has been a “good guy” in the community. However, the question is valid, because the amount a franchise-holder donates is an indicator of just how much profit is being taken. How much is too much, when you are operating under an agreement that is supposedly in the interest of taxpayers?
Entertainment expenses are the more important item, and thankfully Smyth is keeping it on the table— and planning to make each council member accountable for his or her vote on it. Analyzing entertainment expenses should not be an exceedingly costly item, and the only conceivable reason council members would refrain from asking the question is if they do not want to see the answer.
Make no mistake: The council has agreed on various items for the audit that should help the city get to the bottom of the situation. Among those are queries into the methods used to set trash collection fees, and the methods to record the amounts of waste dumped in landfills and the amounts of material recycled.
But when council members balk at the sexy stuff— things like questions about the haulers’ entertainment expenses— or when they balk at an audit of a hauler under its former, well-connected ownership, there is only one conclusion taxpayers could draw: Our council isn’t looking after us. The council is looking after the politically connected and the influential.
If that’s the case, Santa Claritans had better take a hard look at who their leaders are.
