The City Council did the right thing.
In unanimously approving an audit of the city’s trash franchises dating back to 1995, all five council members stepped up to the plate and acted in the interests of all Santa Clarita taxpayers, rather than an influential few.
It was more than just a victory for those who have advocated an audit of the trash franchises over the past few months as questions have arisen about high local trash rates and discrepancies in the city’s waste diversion statistics.
It was a victory for anyone who wants truth in local government, anyone who believes government— and government franchises— should operate under the bright light of close scrutiny.
And it was a victory for the City Council itself— not necessarily for the individual elected members, but for the Santa Clarita City Council as an institution representing the community.
Not all five council members were enthused about the audit, its scope and its cost. And not all five were pleased by the series of events that led to Tuesday’s vote, as a variety of side issues complicated the picture— ranging from disputes over the performance of City Manager George Caravalho to a former city employee’s lawsuit in which she claims she was squelched when she tried to blow the whistle on the city’s inflated trash rates in 1996.
But this audit is not just about Caravalho. It is not just about the performance of any one individual. It is not a personal matter targeting any local individual in the waste hauling industry.
It is about seeking the truth. It is about the City Council living up to its fiduciary duty to act in the interests of all of the city’s taxpayers.
And yes, if the truth indicates there were individuals who engaged in misconduct, maybe there should be consequences. Maybe not. Maybe whatever will be found can be chalked up to simple human error, and we’ll all move on with a difficult lesson learned.
It could be that the most significant consequence is a better understanding at City Hall of what must be done to ensure the best possible deal for taxpayers before the city makes its final decision on whether to sign new contracts with the haulers who have operated under the franchise agreements since 1991: Santa Clarita Disposal, Blue Barrel and Atlas Disposal.
The three haulers were originally local companies, but each has since come under the ownership of a national conglomerate. Representatives of the haulers— past and present— have influential friends at City Hall, both elected and appointed. And going into Tuesday’s vote, there was some question about just how in-depth — or not— the audit would be.
In a previous meeting, several council members had balked at the notion of investigating sensitive items like the haulers’ expenses incurred while entertaining city officials, and Councilman Bob Kellar had advocated that Santa Clarita Disposal be excluded from the audit for the pre-1998 period during which it was owned by Steve Arklin, who is a friend of Kellar and Caravalho.
But on Tuesday, Kellar and the rest of the council did the right thing, approving an audit of all of the haulers dating back to 1995, and including items like entertainment expenses and charitable contributions.
Councilman Cameron Smyth especially deserves a great deal of credit for pushing for the most thorough audit possible, and for pressing his fellow council members to do what’s right.
The audit is expected to cost the city several hundred thousand dollars, perhaps as much as a half-million dollars. That cost may sound daunting, but it must be viewed in the proper context: Even conservatively, it appears that, based on incorrect landfill fees used by the city in a 1996 residential rate adjustment, local taxpayers have overpaid by several million dollars in the ensuing five years.
Even if that is the only glitch detailed in an audit, would it be worth it to the city to spend a half-million dollars to save several millions more over the course of the new franchise contracts?
Some observers expect the audit to reveal much more than that, but regardless, the audit is expected to provide something that the city has never demanded in its decade of overseeing trash franchises:
The truth.
