Frank Waldrop was a 52-year-old high school social studies teacher in Lago Vista, Texas, in 1993 when police officers found him naked in the woods — accompanied by one of his 15-year-old students.
The girl, Alida Star Gebser, later said she and Waldrop had a sexual relationship for about six months before that fateful day. Waldrop was fired and stripped of his teaching credential when the school district heard of the incident, and Gebser and her mother filed a sexual harassment lawsuit against Waldrop and the district.
The question is, who should pay?
Gebser's lawsuit has sought to hold the Texas high school district's taxpayers liable, asserting that the district is to blame even though none of Waldrop's superiors had been informed of the affair until the 9th grader and her teacher were caught together in the woods.
The case wound its way all the way to the Supreme Court, and last week, the High Court, sharply divided on the issue, made the correct ruling: If the school district did not know about the sexual relationship, it could not be reasonably expected to end it.
Justice Sandra Day O'Connor wrote for the court: "Damages may not be recovered ... unless an official of the school district who at a minimum has authority to institute corrective measures on the district's behalf has actual notice of, and is deliberately indifferent to, the teacher's misconduct."
The 5-4 decision makes it more difficult for students to attack the deep pockets of public school districts in instances when district officials or a teacher's supervisors did not know about an allegation of improper conduct. The case does not have a direct impact on sexual harassment in other workplaces, but it could set the stage for rulings by the court in similar cases that would apply to the private sector.
For now, the ruling offers a level of protection to well-meaning school officials who are unaware of an employee's criminal behavior. Protecting students from sexual harassment by adults who should know better is an absolute must. But the court correctly found that it's unreasonable to expect a district to take corrective action when it is unaware that a problem exists.
Should school districts be expected to exercise due caution in hiring teachers? Of course — but the most careful screening in the world won't prevent a teacher from committing a first offense if he or she becomes so inclined. That's why open lines of communication between students and administrations are so important, and it's a reason why school administrators should always be on the lookout for questionable behavior.
But when a wayward teacher and a student sneak off into the woods after school hours to engage in an unacceptable, secret relationship, school district officials' only means of preventing it would be clairvoyance.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
