It was a study in studies: Two reports, prepared by different consultants, about the effects the proposed Newhall Ranch development could have on the city of Santa Clarita.
One study, prepared for the city by city staff and the consulting firm Ultra-Research, estimates the planned 24,000-home development west of Santa Clarita would cost the city $530,000 per year.
The other, prepared by The Levander Co. for Los Angeles County and The Newhall Land and Farming Co., projected Newhall Ranch would have a net $1.8 million annual positive impact on the city.
The math, oversimplified, illustrates a $2.33 million difference between the perception of the city vs. the perception of the county and the developer of the proposed 70,000-resident community.
At issue in these reports is whether the city's revenue from by the development — via sales tax dollars that are generated by Newhall Ranchers' visits to Santa Clarita stores and shopping malls — offset the costs the city will face as a result of the project, in terms of things like added burdens on city programs and services.
The conflicting results of the reports illustrate a basic truth about consultants' studies: You can pretty much make them say what you want them to say, depending on your perspective.
Obviously, the county and Newhall Land would like to portray it as having a net positive effect on the city, since it would be in the best interest of neither to give up any more concessions than necessary to allay Santa Clarita's concerns.
And, the city's interests are best served if it is concluded that Santa Clarita should get a great deal of compensation to offset the impact.
The truth, of course, probably lies somewhere between the findings of the two studies.
It's imperative that, when the final deal is reached for Newhall Ranch, the city be kept whole. That means the project should include enough compensation for the city to cover the added cost not only of providing services to the new non-city residents, but also costs that will be incurred to expand the local road network and other infrastructure that will bear the additional burden of tens of thousands of new residents.
That adjustment can come in various forms, perhaps in a tax shift from Los Angeles County and concessions from the developer, maybe including revisions to scale back the project or extra fees to help offset city costs.
The answer to the question of how much compensation is sufficient will depend on the true impact of Newhall Ranch on its prospective neighbor to the east.
What is that magic number? How much impact will Newhall Ranch have on Santa Clarita's coffers?
Given the results of the studies, it's safe to say that it's somewhere between minus-$530,000 or $1.8 million every year.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
