John Steffen isn't the most popular guy in town. He often uses his three minutes at the microphone during city meetings to chide the City Council, usually on the subject of development.
That's his right. That's everyone's right under the Ralph M. Brown open meeting law.
Steffen sued the city when mayor Jan Heidt stopped him from speaking freely during an April council meeting.
Heidt wanted to maintain a particular decorum at the meeting. Three council members were being sworn into office that night, and the council chambers were packed with well-wishers. But it was still an open meeting of a governmental agency, and Steffen still had the right to make a statement, disagreeable though it may have been to the council and most of the audience.
On Monday, Steffen and the city settled out of court.
Steffen called it "a victory for the citizens of Santa Clarita."
But what exactly did Steffen — or the citizens of Santa Clarita — win? Not much.
It certainly wasn't a "victory." You don't "win" a settlement.
More to the point, Steffen's lawsuit hasn't really changed anything.
The city read this statement into the court record: "John Steffen and any member of the public will be free to speak three minutes during any appropriate public comment portion (of a city meeting) without interference as to the content of their remarks so long as there is no objective disturbance of the meeting caused by the speaker."
The irony is, that's already city policy. Always has been. The only difference is that it was unwritten before, and now it's in writing.
The policy was compromised when Heidt didn't like what Steffen had to say during his three minutes and tried to shut him down early, and for that, Steffen may be in line to receive some taxpayer money in compensation.
You have to wonder. Since the city managed to skirt a high-profile court trial, will the entire incident get swept under the rug? Let's hope not.
The public has the right to address governmental agencies, whether or not the comments are as nice as the elected officials might like them to be. Government in a free society isn't about nice. It's about representation.
John Steffen can legally be barred from inciting a riot at a council meeting. Short of that, he can speak his mind for three full minutes, whether he's happy, sad, angry, or out of line with the "atmosphere" of the room.
Hopefully the council has learned something.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
