Only parents who have endured the death of a child can fully comprehend the grief that comes with such a loss. For most parents, it’s unimaginable, a situation we pray will never confront us.
Survivors cope in different ways, and one mechanism for a group of local parents has been the planting of sycamore trees along Cedarcreek Street in Canyon Country to honor the memory of their children. Nothing can replace the children they have lost, but they have taken some solace in nurturing the trees, caring for them.
Among the 10 trees was one planted in memory of Michelle Nicole Briones, who died in a car accident at age 20.
Another was in memory of Andrew Aguilar, who suffered a fatal asthma attack. He was 19.
Their parents, and others, added some individual touches to those sycamore trees, placing photos of their beloved children on the trees, turning them into more personal memorials of the young lives tragically cut short.
All in all, it was a fairly harmless way for the parents to help themselves cope with the trauma of losing a child. But you can see where this is going:
Someone had to complain.
Apparently a couple of nearby residents complained two weeks ago to the city’s Field Services Department, which had no choice but to comply with the complainers and remove the photos because they did not adhere to the letter of the law. Since the trees are in a public right of way, the parents would have needed a permit from the city in order to post the photos.
Those complaints, it seems, echoed the sentiment of one area resident who had told one of the parents that “such things belonged at a grave site.”
The residents who complained told city officials the photos should come down because the residents became depressed by the photos’ presence, and it made the area look like a cemetery.
So, down the photos came— following a similar pattern to a plaque that one parent had placed at the foot of one of the sycamores. The plaque was removed by the city in December because it, like the photos, was not in compliance with the municipal code.
Under the letter of the law, the city and the complainers are right: The trees are in a public right of way, and we can’t have people posting photos and signs and memorials all over public rights of way, willy nilly, without regard to the generally reasonable rules and regulations that are established in the interest of creating a livable, orderly city.
But couldn’t this situation have been handled in a more human manner?
The “letter of the law” is one thing, and we have laws for reasons. However, this was clearly a special set of circumstances, and these were clearly people who meant no harm to anyone. They were just trying to express their love for the children who were taken from them all too early.
While no one wants their neighborhood to look like a cemetery, it’s difficult to imagine the lack of compassion that would drive someone to tell a grieving parent that “such things belong at a grave site,” then to call the local government and demand the removal of a photograph of someone’s dead child.
There must have been a better, more compassionate way to handle it than that.
And, while the city staff did what it had to do under the circumstances, perhaps some creativity can now be employed to make the situation right with all concerned.
For example, can the parents be given the opportunity to work with the city to devise a tasteful, discreet plaque or band marking each tree, indicating that it was dedicated in the memory of a certain individual?
Indeed, what would be so wrong about dedicating a tree, in any public right of way, to the memory of an individual, with a small, tasteful plaque, provided it is not done at public expense?
Could the survivors’ desire to personalize the tribute be met, while still addressing the inevitable complaints about prominent displays of photos and “distracting” memorials? Could this evolve into a program in which citizens can memorialize their loved ones by planting new trees around town, in cooperation with the city?
The city ought to look into such ideas, and try to devise a way for well-meaning tributes like that on Cedarcreek Street to be handled without offending the sensibilities of those among us who lack compassion.
We can’t all comprehend the grief of those who have lost a child— but this kind of gesture is one way we can all help them try to cope.
