John Rezendes-Herrick is not going to jail. Under average circumstances, that wouldn’t be news. But Rezendes-Herrick is a former reporter for the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, and until recently, he was confronted with the possibility of a $500 fine and a prison sentence for refusing to reveal his news sources to a San Bernardino County jury investigating business crimes.
Rezendes-Herrick was looking into a business called Cadiz Land Co. He wrote an article about the company, and the effect of its operations on a small Arizona town. During his research, the reporter received a package of materials and a tip to visit Hyder, Ariz.; allegedly, the information came from a rival company of Cadiz Land.
That rival, the allegation goes, was conspiring to devalue Cadiz stock by spreading false information about the company.
That’s a situation reporters face often. Journalists have to be extremely cautious that they’re not being used, manipulated by one side or another, whether they’re reporting on businesses or the goings-on in government.
Rezendes-Herrick was called into court and asked to name his sources in the Cadiz Land story. He refused, under California’s press “shield law.” Superior Court Judge J. Michael Welch issued an order finding the reporter in contempt.
But the Fourth District Court of Appeal overturned Welch’s decision, maintaining the original meaning and intent of the shield law, in the wake of a finding by another appellate court that the shield law isn’t “bulletproof” against a prosecutor’s demand for information.
The law may not be bulletproof, but it should be as close as possible. Journalists require as much protection as priests or lawyers when it comes to protecting their sources.
Sources— those concerned citizens who look to a newspaper or television news organization for help when all other government or legal sources have failed— often have good reasons to request protection of their identities. Sometimes they, themselves, are government employees who suspect incompetence, apathy or outright corruption is taking place. They’ve gone through the proper channels and the problems they see haven’t been addressed. So they turn to a reporter. But they’re not interested in losing their jobs. The same is true of dozens of others every day.
Citizens have to feel secure with contacting a news organization and expressing a concern. The shield law is really meant to protect readers and viewers, not reporters. In the case of John Rezendes-Herrick ’s sources, it worked. It always should.
