When a prominent local high school and college football star was accused of rape several years ago, we pointed out that, regardless of the outcome of the case, a tragedy had occurred:
‘The news is the news, and there is no way to report that someone is accused of a crime without having some people draw their own conclusions. But it remains important for all of us to reserve judgment until the DA has pressed charges, a jury has heard the evidence and a verdict has been reached.’
If the young man had in fact raped his ex-girlfriend as she claimed, the 17-year-old girl would have been the victim of a tragic, brutal sexual assault.
And if the 18-year-old athlete were wrongly accused, that would have been tragic, too, because he would have been, in the minds of many, branded as a rape suspect regardless of whether he was ultimately cleared.
In that particular case, the one-time suspect was cleared after a judge tossed out the indictment against him, largely due to the prior sexual relationship between him and the girl. He has, thus, never been convicted of rape— but his name to this day reminds many of the unproven accusation leveled against him.
Now, for two different people in our community, such an inevitable conclusion is again evident: A tragedy has occurred.
A 22-year-old woman says she was raped outside a Saugus sports bar on the night of July 15— and, sheriff’s officials say, she has identified her attacker as a 26-year-old Canyon Country man.
The district attorney’s office announced Monday that it had declined to file charges against the man because the woman remains too traumatized by the alleged attack to corroborate the details of the incident.
Did the man rape her?
If the answer to that question is yes, then obviously we have a situation in which the woman was the victim of a horrible crime, and the perpetrator must be brought to justice.
But all too often, we forget about the other possible answer to that question: The suspect has not been convicted, and if the answer to that question is no, then the suspect would have been wrongly— and quite publicly— accused of an abhorrent act.
The point?
The news is the news, and there is no way to report that someone is accused of a crime without having some people draw their own conclusions. But it remains important for all of us to reserve judgment until the DA has pressed charges, a jury has heard the evidence and a verdict has been reached.
In the case of the rape that was reported the night of July 15, none of those things have happened yet.
