Golf course developer Ted Robinson Jr. has a point: Why should he pay for more water than he needs?
That is the central issue of a dispute between the Castaic Lake Water Agency and Robinson over his Robinson Ranch Golf Course in Sand Canyon. And after a six-month dispute, it appears the two sides are close to settling their differences.
Hopefully, that will prove true.
Robinson in February sued the CLWA, accusing the state water retailer of price gouging in its demand that the golf course developer pay a “facility capacity fee” for golf course irrigation— a fee that could top the $4 million mark.
This, despite the fact that Robinson had found his own source of well water to irrigate the golf course.
What! Robinson did need, however, was service from Santa Clarita Water Co. to provide water to the golf course clubhouse. Santa Clarita Water, which is now owned by CLWA, balked at the fees Robinson was willing to pay, saying they were insufficient. Robinson contends the water company has been sandbagging while the CLWA pushes for the facility capacity fee.
In the meantime, Robinson has managed to open both 18-hole courses at Robinson Ranch and construction has proceeded on the 73 homes that accompany the golf course.
Since the lawsuit was filed, Robinson has pursued state legislation— being carried by Sen. Don Perata, D-Oakland — that would prevent water agencies from unilaterally deciding how much water a new development will need. Instead, the legislation would allow a water agency to charge only for water it provides.
In other words, if a developer like Robinson! has his own source of water for irrigation, the bill would prevent the CLWA from charging him for the water anyway. After all, says Robinson: “If a developer finds an alternate source for water, why should it have to pay?”
That makes sense.
Robinson says, however, if the settlement talks work out, he’ll back off on the legislation.
For Robinson’s case, that probably makes sense— although it would still leave the door open for water agencies to charge excessive fees should a similar situation arise.
CLWA officials have declined comment, and details of the possible settlement have yet to be made known. But it is encouraging to hear that the two sides are close to agreeing on a deal that will clear the way for Robinson to put the finishing touches on the Sand Canyon development.
What’s unfortunate is that it has taken this long.
