The state Senate and Assembly have agreed unanimously on legislation that’s designed to improve the procedures courts
‘A journalist should only be forced to disclose confidential or unpublished information when the information cannot be obtained from another source and it is vital in order for a criminal defendant to receive a fair trial.’
use to balance the sometimes conflicting rights of criminal defendants and journalists who have promised to protect confidential sources.
Now, it’s up to Gov. Gray Davis.
The governor should sign Assembly Bill 1860, authored by Assemblywoman Carole Migden, D-San Francisco.
The bill is designed to reinforce a journalist’s protection under the California Shield Law, which protects a journalist’s right not to divulge unpublished information or identify confidential sources. These rights can be crucial in the media’s role as a government watchdog.
Migden, bothered by criminal defense attorneys’ fishing expeditions in which they demand unpublished information from journalists, put forth the proposed new rules in hopes of forcing those attorneys to better rely on their own powers of investigation.
The assemblywoman, working in conjunction with the California Newspaper Publishers Association, developed a proposed set of procedures to guide courts in cases involving shield law issues.
AB 1860 would establish that no testimony given by a journalist under subpoena will be construed as a waiver of the journalist’s rights under the shield law. Also, the bill would require five days’ notice to subpoenaed journalists in most cases— and require the party issuing the subpoena to provide in writing the basis upon which it is believed the journalist’s testimony is necessary in order for a defendant to receive a fair trial. Similar requirements would be imposed on courts that hold journalists in contempt for refusing to divulge information.
A journalist should only be forced to disclose confidential or unpublished information when the information cannot be obtained from another source and it is vital in order for a criminal defendant to receive a fair trial. That concept, however, has been abused in recent years— and without legislation like AB 1860, it’s easy to envision courts and criminal attorneys beginning to view the media as an investigatory tool.
That’s not the way it should be, and AB 1860 would bolster the necessary protection offered by the shield law. Hopefully, Gov. Davis will agree.
