The Porta Bella property owners have reached the pinnacle of doubletalk. They want the city to change the rules so they can develop their contaminated land in phases, yet they file a lawsuit when the city bends the same rules to build a road.
Here is what it’s all about: In 1995, the city approved plans for 2,911 homes and other buildings on 996 acres southeast of Bouquet Junction, where explosives were made and tested for most of the century. In 1996 the council signed a development agreement that essentially promised the owners they’d be allowed to build the community of Porta Bella.
Two years earlier, the property owner, Whittaker Corp., signed a legally binding agreement with the state Environmental Protection Agency, promising to remove all the chemicals left behind from the weapon-making . A key provision of the city’s 1996 development agreement with Whittaker was that no homes could be built until the entire 996 acres were clean.
Over the next few years, Whittaker sold off its nonperforming assets, one of which was the Porta Bella property.
Enter Remediation Financial Inc., an Arizona company that cleans and redevelops contaminated properties, known as brownfields. As many developers do, RFI formed a separate company, Santa Clarita LLC, to acquire and manage the Porta Bella property.
Santa Clarita LLC financed the deal by taking out loans in late 1998, promising lenders that it would clean, develop and sell off the land in phases, with proceeds being used to repay the loans. Santa Clarita LLC would then take out more loans to clean and sell more sections of the property until it came to the final section, when proceeds would be divided up with the original seller— Whittaker.
Funny thing is, that stipulation of the 1996 development agreement was still on the books: the one that said the entire 996 acres had to be clean before any homes could be built.
We don’t know who promised what to whom, but four months after Santa Clarita LLC borrowed its money to buy the property, the city signed a non-binding document in which it agreed to “(proceed) with the negotiation and approval of amendments” to the 1996 development agreement, so the property owner could clean and develop the land in phases. The non-binding document did not, in itself, change the rules outlined in the development agreement.
The city wanted to push a portion of the cross-valley connector, Golden Valley Road, through the property. Also, the city had been leasing the Santa Clarita Metrolink Station from the Porta Bella property owners virtually free of charge since 1992, and the lease was expiring.
Several things happened in the two years since the city singed this non-binding agreement. On the upside, state officials gave the go-ahead for the city to start building Golden Valley Road. The city obtained funds for that purpose, and the project is in the works.
On the downside, Santa Clarita LLC hasn’t started any cleanup activities. Instead its contractors say they’re owed money, and the company owes several hundred thousand dollars more to the state.
Moreover, Santa Clarita LLC broke an important term of the development agreement when it failed to cover the city under its insurance policy. The city could wind up a big loser, at taxpayer expense, if problems from contamination or unexploded munitions lead to a lawsuit.
Santa Clarita LLC wants the city to “make good” on its non-binding agreement to let it clean and sell the property in phases. The trouble is twofold: It appears the groundwater beneath the entire site is contaminated; and the city would face even greater liability if a construction worker or a Porta Bella home buyer is injured when something explodes or the toxic waste spreads.
Santa Clarita LLC is trying to play hardball to get “phasing.” It filed a lawsuit alleging the city broke the terms of the very same development agreement it wants changed, by starting work on Golden Valley Road. And, in a completely undiplomatic manner, it has denied the city access to its section of Golden Valley Road and canceled the city’s lease for the Metrolink station.
So be it. The Metrolink station was problematic and temporary from the beginning, and now that location, too, appears to be contaminated.
Golden Valley Road is a far more difficult situation. The city has the option to take the roadbed by eminent domain. Tonight, when the City Council meets in closed session to discuss the lawsuit, it should consider doing that— or figure out how to redesign the road so it doesn’t run through Porta Bella.
