So it has come to this. The city of Santa Clarita has locked horns with the owners of the proposed Porta Bella development site, each side pawing at the dirt and making ready for what could be a nasty legal battle.
And we’ll say this for the members of the City Council:
They didn’t blink first.
The council, after a three-hour closed session Thursday evening, voted unanimously (although insiders speculate that one of those votes was a reluctant one) to fight the lawsuit filed against the city by Santa Clarita LLC.
They did the right thing.
The council’s decision at once risks the immediate future of Santa Clarita’s primary Metrolink station— which has been leased at minimal cost from Santa Clarita LLC— yet protects the overall interests of city residents, who clearly would not have been well-served if the council had simply rolled over and yielded to the property owner’s demands.
At issue is whether the city has violated the terms of the 1996 development agreement that was intended to pave the way for the development of the 2, 911-home Porta Bella development, on the condition that the builder first rid the entire 996-acre site of some 275 different contaminants.
The toxic waste is what remains of a decades-long munitions operation, as the property was the site of the Bermite explosives manufacturing company. The defense contractor left behind waste, including rocket fuel byproducts, that has seeped into the soil and even into the area’s underground water supplies.
Santa Clarita LLC, a subsidiary of Arizona-based Remediation Financial Inc., purchased the property from its longtime owner, Whittaker Corp., in 1999—Êand assumed the responsibility for cleaning up the site.
Ignoring, for now, the marketability challenges of selling 2,911 homes on a former toxic wasteland, the question in court will be whether one side— or, more likely, both sides— violated the letter of that 1996 development agreement.
Santa Clarita LLC is financially strapped and desperate, evidently hoping to use its lawsuit as a means of persuading the city to allow the project to be developed in phases.
The city should stick to its guns, and should not allow the residential portion of the project to be done in phases, as Santa Clarita LLC wants. The potential liability is too severe, especially considering the fact that, despite the development agreement’s stipulation that the city would be indemnified via the property owner’s insurance, Santa Clarita LLC has never added the city to its insurance policy.
It’s ironic, then, that the property owner has gone after the city for allegedly violating the terms of the agreement. At least upon cursory review, it has the appearance of a pot-and-kettle sort of situation.
Santa Clarita LLC has attempted to play hardball in its attempt to get phasing for Porta Bella, denying the city access to the segment of Golden Valley Road that is under construction on a sliver of the property, and canceling the city’s lease for the Metrolink commuter rail station just east of Saugus Speedway.
As appealing as the station’s location is, that may be just as well. The property isn’t desirable for the city to purchase, as that would only draw the city deeper into the entanglements that come with owning contaminated property. Contrary to what some observers say, there are likely to be other suitable locations for a central commuter rail station, and the city ought to explore those options immediately. After all, Santa Clarita LLC, burning its latest fastball over the plate, has indicated the existing station— the busiest of three in Santa Clarita— will be shut down at the end of the month unless the city yields to the property owner’s demands.
The city has certainly had its missteps along the way in dealing with Porta Bella, and there are a variety of curious aspects of this story’s evolution at City Hall. Regardless, the city should not kowtow to a developer demanding phasing that could leave the city high and dry with a contaminated site at Santa Clarita’s core after only a portion of the project is cleaned and built.
And while it may have seemed logical for the city to countersue rather than simply defend, the process of defending the lawsuit will still allow the city to air its arguments. The City Council’s decision Thursday seems to indicate the council will stick to its guns.
As it should.
