The City Council still has a chance to do the right thing.
The city scored a virtual court victory Thursday when a judge tossed out the lawsuit filed by Citizens Against Barricades in an attempt to force the city to open the road link between Valley Street and Calgrove Boulevard.
‘Many of us would like to block
others from using the roads in our neighborhoods. But the fact of the matter is,
the Valley-Calgrove
connection was designed as a public road link and, especially in roads-starved Santa Clarita, should be open to all.’
The Los Angeles County Superior Court decision seems to clear the way for the City Council to proceed with its plan to permanently close off the Valley-Calgrove connection.
That would truly be unfortunate, and once again, we are asking our council to rethink its posture— and do the right thing.
The council’s current policy calls for the installation of permanent cul-de-sacs where Valley Street and Calgrove meet, instead of the through street that was clearly envisioned when the roads were designed.
The connection has been the subject of heated debate for the past decade, as area residents and public officials argued over whether Hidden Valley residents, by way of their own private, gated detour, should continue to have exclusive access to the public road connection.
In a nod to fairness, if the council’s policy is implemented it would deny Hidden Valley residents access to the connection, too, so for the first time at least all Santa Clarita residents would be treated equally when it comes to Valley-Calgrove .
Of course, what it really means is that the city’s decision is equally poor for the vast majority of Santa Claritans.
This is a public road connection, but the council majority on this issue— Laurene Weste, Cameron Smyth and Jo Anne Darcy— has yielded to a group of area residents who contend that opening the link will destroy the rural nature of the neighborhoods on the Valley Street side of the gate.
Surely, we can understand the concern of those residents— and it’s difficult to blame them for trying. Many of us would like to block others from using the roads in our neighborhoods. But the fact of the matter is, the Valley-Calgrove connection was designed as a public road link and, especially in road-starved Santa Clarita, should be open to all, with traffic-calming measures employed to keep the link from becoming a high-speed thoroughfare.
Unfortunately, CAB has yet to succeed in forcing the city to open the road, and it’s unclear whether the legal challenge will return in some form. While it appears unlikely, we sincerely hope the City Council will make that question moot.
Council members Frank Ferry and Bob Kellar, to their credit, have in the past stood in favor of opening the Valley-Calgrove link, recognizing that opening the road would be the right decision for all of their constituents.
Throughout the Valley-Calgrove debate, Kellar and Ferry have been the only two council members who seem to be most concerned with the overall betterment of city traffic circulation patterns rather than catering to a small group of people who wish to effectively block the rest of us from using public roads.
And it would only take one more vote— from Weste, Smyth or Darcy— to change the council’s course and do the right thing.
