One of our favorite stories about the quality of the Santa Clarita Valley jury pool dates all the way back to the 1920s. Forest ranger, poet, Mighty Signal editor, all-around manly-man and part-time posse rider Thornton Doelle got a call that a bank had been robbed in the neighboring Antelope Valley. The gunmen were headed our way.
Mr. Doelle and a rag-tag band of hastily-deputized pistol fighters caught up with desperados holed up in a ranch in present-day Acton. After the smoke cleared from the 3-hour shoot-out, not one SCV marshal was injured. Out of four strong arm artists, two were dead, one was slightly wounded and the other surely had his feelings hurt.
The remainder of the gang was dragged back to the Newhall Jail, and as editor, Doelle dutifully covered the daring robbery and gunfight on the front pages of this very newspaper. Justice was swift. By week's end, the two surviving bank robbers found themselves on trial and we certainly would have liked to have been a fly on the wall to see the villains' reactions when they saw Thornton Doelle sitting sitting impassive on the jury like Zeus Himself.
Doelle and 11 others did their civic duty in near-record time and despite cries of "Foul!" by the bank robbers' attorney, the jury found the two men guilty as Original Sin.
Editor Doelle later theorized, in a story he wrote, that it was easy to cast judgment. After all. He had shot one of the rotters.
Last week, a bill appeared on Gov. Pete Wilson's desk. It was authored by Assemblywoman Carole Midgen (D — San Francisco). The bill passed both houses by unemotional landslides and if the governor signs it, which he probably will, it shall raise juror's pay from $5 to $10 per day, beginning Jan. 1, 1999.
Some companies pay their employees while they are conscripted to hold the scales of justice. Many do not. The results are all too frequently that the jury pools are made up of the elderly, postal workers, the easily-confused and those who have trouble answering the simple question: "It's 2 o'clock in the afternoon. Why aren't you some place important?"
Furthermore, the ongoing anecdotes of frustration are that many citizens who seem to be the very model of common sense are unceremoniously bounced from jury service by hoofed and hump-shouldered defense attorneys who wash their hands with an invisible bar of soap and drool at the chance to trident anyone with a room-temperature IQ out of Lady Justice's coveted box of 12.
What is the solution? Professional juries? A finer mesh on the screening process? A signed note from the asylum administrator? Ox Bow justice where the posse/jury grins toothily at the accused?
A five-buck raise is just ducky. But is there any way to inoculate common sense into our state's jury pools? Please. Let us know at this address should you find a solution to California's judgmentally challenged.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
