The two young men, Charles Butler, Jr., 21, and his buddy Steven Mullins, 25, stood before a judge in Rockford, Ala., Thursday, and had every reason to expect to hear themselves sentenced to death.
They’d both been convicted for the capital murder of Billy Jack Gaither. The two had beaten Gaither to the point of near-death , slashed his throat and fractured his skull with an ax handle. They then burned him atop kerosene-soaked tires, and torched Gaither’s car as well, in an attempt to destroy evidence.
Butler and Mullins’ rationale for this brutality was that Gaither was a homosexual who’d made an “unwanted advance” toward one of them.
There was no doubt of their guilt. Mullins pleaded guilty to the murder and testified against Butler, and Butler blamed Mullins for the killing.
“I was in shock and didn’t know what to do,” after skinhead Mullins cut Gaither’s throat and hit him repeatedly over the head, Butler testified.
But District Attorney Fred Thompson proved Butler had numerous chances to run for help, but “went along every step of the way.”
For those who support the death penalty— as this newspaper does— there has seldom been a case that justified its use more.
But Judge John Rochester sentenced both Butler and Mullins to life without parole. The judge said he had no choice, under Alabama law, as prosecutor Thompson didn’t seek a death sentence.
And Thompson said he didn’t ask for death for Mullins and Butler because he was acting at the request of the family: victim Gaither’s family.
Billy Jack Gaither’s father, Marion, said he hoped his 39-year-old son would be remembered not as a gay murder victim, but as a loving son, “one of the finest sons a man could want.”
“We don’t believe in the death penalty,” Billy Jack’s brother Randy said, as the Gaither family hugged outside the courtroom following the verdicts. “The only one who’s got a right to take a life is God.”
Between advocates and opponents of capital punishment, the advocates often use the argument that opponents should wait until it a capital crime “happens to someone in their family.”
And even some death penalty opponents admit that, while they’re against the practice theoretically, they don’t know how they’d react if a loved one was brutally murdered. It’s one thing to have convictions, and it’s another thing altogether to have the courage to back them up under the most adverse of circumstances.
The Gaithers know. Agree with their position or not, they stood firm in their convictions under circumstances the rest of us hope to never experience.
Randy Gaither said of his dead brother, “I know (he) knows what’s going on and he’s pleased.” If Randy’s right, his brother has reason to be pleased— and proud.
