What George W. Bush seems to be discovering is that he can’t have it both ways.
The Texas governor and GOP presidential front-runner has become more than a little bent out of shape the last few days when reporters again brought up the issue of Bush’s alleged history of drug use. He assumed a stance he’d taken in the past: moral indignation, not necessarily on his personal behalf (he said), but on behalf of the American political discourse, and the sorry state into which it’s fallen.
“You know what happens?” Bush lectured a journalist Wednesday who sought to question him about past drug use. “Somebody floats a rumor and that causes you to ask a question. And that’s the game in American politics, and I refuse to play it. That is a game. And you just fell for the trap. And I refuse to play.”
Bush has a point. A political campaign has gotten to look more like a soap opera over the past 25 years than a debate over the issues which shape the future of our society: Who’s a drunk, a junkie, an adulterer, who has slept with whom when how often, and what were they smoking/drinking/thinking at the time? It’s gotten ludicrous, going all the way back to Jimmy Carter’s 1976 statement that he’d many times “had lust in (his) heart,” up to and surpassing Bill Clinton’s notorious claim of never inhaling.
But Bush seems to want to ignore the fact that a politician’s past is not only fair game, but also required reading during a race. Every office contender from George Washington to Andrew Jackson to Teddy Roosevelt to John Kennedy to George Bush the Elder has exploited an impressive war record when it was available.
And while at first seeming to take a moral high ground, refusing to discuss past indiscretions at all, Bush then relented and said he hadn’t used drugs in seven years, then on Thursday said it’s been at least 25 years (Bush was then 28); this was added to his earlier statements that he stopped drinking when he was 40 and that he’d been faithful to his wife for 20 years.
Someone needs to explain to the Texas governor that the moral sword doesn’t cut both ways. He either sticks to his guns and maintains that the issues, not his personal past— whether laudatory or not— is what he’s interested in discussing, or he goes with full disclosure. He can’t trumpet marital fidelity on one hand, yet refuse to answer inquiries about alleged drug use on the other.
That, ultimately, is the game in American politics. And if Bush really doesn’t wish to play, he always has the alternative of leaving the field.
