Even to the most casual of observers, it’s a moral and ethical conflict of interest— and it remains to be seen whether it is a legal conflict of interest, too:
Ed Dunn, an anti-growth member of the Castaic Lake Water Agency board of directors, has refused to remove himself from the board’s closed-session discussions of a lawsuit challenging the agency’s decision to purchase the Santa Clarita Water Co.
Dunn’s wife, Joan, is a plaintiff in the lawsuit, along with Santa Clarita Councilwoman Jill Klajic and activists Lynne Plambeck and Jackie Bentencort.
Make no mistake: This lawsuit is about a lot more than whether the CLWA, a state water wholesaler, should get into the business of running a water retailer, the Santa Clarita Water Co. It’s more about control than anything else. The water company is widely viewed as an extremely important entity in Santa Clarita, where the valley’s future growth is a subject of intense debate.
Dunn has a history of using shady tactics— like his well-publicized decision to identify himself on last year’s ballot as a “water resources consultant,” despite the fact that he’s never provided the public with evidence that he has made a living at such a profession. So it should come as no surprise that, when his wife is party to a lawsuit against the agency, he refuses to do the morally and ethically correct thing, and excuse himself from the agency’s closed-session defense talks.
Public agencies, of course, are expected to do the vast majority of their business in public. However, pending litigation is one specific exemption in state open-meeting law, and it’s there for good reason: When a public agency is involved in a lawsuit, confidentiality can be crucial when discussing things like defense strategy.
In such instances, it is in an agency’s best interests to hold closed-session talks in order to prepare the best possible case.
Dunn has taken that ability away from the CLWA.
His fellow board member, Santa Clarita Water President Bill Mannetta, did the right thing: He excused himself from Wednesday night’s closed session— and criticized Dunn for failing to do so.
“It’s an obvious conflict of interest when your wife sues the agency,” Mannetta said, “and then you as a director continue to sit in on a closed session strategy to defend that lawsuit. It is morally wrong in my opinion, but that is something I would expect from Ed Dunn.”
Klajic, one of Dunn’s allies in the battle to use water as a means to control growth, argued that Dunn should be allowed to attend the CLWA closed sessions because Mayor Jo Anne Darcy, who also serves as field deputy to county Supervisor Mike Antonovich, has long participated in council closed sessions regarding matters involving the county.
If two wrongs made a right, Klajic’s argument would make a lot of sense. This newspaper has long held that Darcy’s dual role puts her in sometimes untenable positions, and under no circumstances should Darcy participate in closed sessions about matters involving her employer.
But the fact that Darcy’s council colleagues, the public and the city attorney’s office have allowed that to occur does not justify Dunn’s behavior.
And even if Dunn’s participation in closed sessions turns out to be legal— a matter that is so far unconfirmed— it remains immoral and unethical.
