The message was clear:
We don’t care much whether you oppose our mining plan, and we don’t care much whether you plan to fight it. We’re going to do it anyway, this site is going to be mined and if you don’t like, it, tough.
That much was obvious when officials of Southdown Corp., the parent company of Transit Mixed Concrete, brought their dog and pony show to City Hall on Tuesday night.
‘The attitude of Southdown officials was a figurative nose-thumbing at Santa Clarita.’
It smelled like the sort of token meeting a project applicant might conduct just to be able to say something like, “We’ve discussed this with the community... ” before ramrodding the project down the unwilling throats of neighbors who object.
What’s unfortunate is, that may be their right.
It’s still up for debate, but Southdown contends that the locally backed effort to fight the Transit Mixed mine at the county level is a pointless endeavor. They say they don’t need the approval of Los Angeles County— and that the federal government, specifically the Bureau of Land Management, holds all the cards.
If that proves to be the case, it leaves the city of Santa Clarita at a crossroads: Do we fight the Transit Mixed plan with everything we’ve got, or do we try to extract whatever concessions we can from the mining company? As one observer noted of the Southdown presentation, the mitigation they have offered so far is “chicken feed” when considered in the context of the very significant impacts the Transit Mixed aggregate mine would have on the community.
The proposed decades-long mining operation would be located near existing residential areas, just beyond the eastern boundary of the city of Santa Clarita in Canyon Country.
Transit Mixed would extract aggregate— needed to produce concrete— from the hills of Soledad Canyon, and the site would be perched upslope from the Santa Clara River and the Santa Clarita Valley’s underground drinking water supplies.
The operation would pour heavy truck traffic onto the already congested State Route 14, and blasting associated with the mining would spew dust— and who knows what else— into the air.
In short, the project isn’t likely to be a good neighbor.
The distasteful irony is, Southdown could put the mine in a more remote location, but the cost of delivering concrete aggregate would increase. So Santa Clarita residents will pay the price.
Given the project’s impacts, it ought to bring serious concessions to the table for the local community— perhaps something substantial like an entire new lane of SR14 from the mining site to the Interstate 5 interchange.
But nothing of the sort has been offered. Southdown clearly does not care about its impacts on the people of Santa Clarita.
Although it has been a decade in the making, Tuesday night marked the first time Southdown has made much of a show of checking in with the community. Even then, the attitude of Southdown officials was a figurative nose-thumbing at Santa Clarita: Oppose us if you want, but it’s inevitable. We don’t need your blessing and we don’t need the county.
It makes one wonder who in Washington is in Southdown’s back pocket, and whether anyone there cares whether a project like this— so near an already populated area— will have a major impact on existing residents.
Clearly, the city will have to carefully evaluate Southdown’s assertion that the BLM can play God with the fate of the proposed Soledad Canyon mining site. And if that appears to be the case, the tough question must be answered:
Do we keep trying to beat them— at significant local taxpayer cost— or do we try to cut our losses by negotiating with Southdown?
Whatever course is chosen, there is a major cost for this community: We fight it and spend numerous local taxpayer dollars, or we roll over, dance with the devil and accept a bad new neighbor.
And if Southdown is right, they will have to forgive this community if we don’t welcome them into town with open arms once they have shoved this bitter pill down our throats.
