Goodness, even the IRS has a heart. It's a teeny-weeny, dark, Grinch-like one, but it's there.
This fact came into evidence Tuesday when, after a national outcry, the Internal Revenue Service backed off from its announced position that the lucky fan who catches Mark McGwire's record-breaking home run ball would be subject to a tax bill of $150,000 — or more — if the ball were given back to the St. Louis Cardinals slugger.
That's right. The IRS had promised to tax a baseball.
The ball in question is the much-anticipated 62nd home-run ball of the season to be hit by McGwire, breaking Roger Maris' hallowed, 37-year-old Major League record of 61.
McGwire tied the record on Monday with a first-inning storybook shot before his team's home fans: It was his 61st homer of the season, with his 10-year-old son in attendance as a batboy and his father in the stands, ironically, celebrating his 61st birthday.
He broke the record in Tuesday night's game against the Chicago Cubs, with a line-drive homer in the fourth inning.
The question of the week, throughout America, became: What would you do if you caught the ball?
The ball that breaks the record is estimated to be worth as much as $1 million on the collectors' market, and the temptation would surely be there to cash in on the good fortune of catching the ball. McGwire and many baseball purists say the ball should end up in the Baseball Hall of Fame, and as he has done with several individuals who have caught home-run balls on his march toward the record, McGwire has said he'll gladly exchange signed jerseys, bats, and other memorabilia for the ball that breaks the record. Then, continuing his classy handling of his historic season, McGwire says he would donate the ball to the Hall of Fame.
Always able to spoil a good party, enter the IRS: The tax collectors announced that an individual who catches the ball, then gives it to McGwire, would be subject to a 40 percent gift tax based on the ball's value.
Taking into account every citizen's lifetime exemption of $625,000, if the ball were found to be worth, say, $1 million, the 40 percent tax on the remaining $375,000 would be $150,000.
If you're Joe Sixpack in the outfield bleachers and you catch the home-run ball of a lifetime, then do the "right" thing by giving it to McGwire for enshrinement in the Hall of Fame, wouldn't it rankle to be hit with a tax bill so hefty it puts you in the poorhouse?
If you're a profiteer and you sell it to the highest bidder, that's one thing; but to tax someone who passes up a chance at a cool million in order to honor the tradition of sport? That's just plain mean.
The IRS announcement brought on a wave of criticism, not only from rank-and-file taxpayers but also from some baseball fans in Washington.
Said House Minority Leader Dick Gephardt, D-Mo., a huge Cardinals fan who represents part of St. Louis: "Only the IRS could turn a once-in-a-lifetime event into a once-in-a-lifetime Catch 22."
And, White House spokesman Mike McCurry called it "about the dumbest thing I've ever heard in my life."
No kidding. It conjured images of tax men hovering in the ballpark's shadows, vulture-like, waiting to converge on the unsuspecting fan who dropped his peanuts and braced himself against a surge from his bleacher-mates to catch the souvenir of a lifetime.
Thankfully, the IRS heard the criticism and reversed course, announcing on Tuesday that it was mistaken: Since the situation could be likened to returning "unwanted" merchandise or declining a prize in a raffle, an individual who gives back the record-breaking ball would not be taxed.
It was a nice "out" for the IRS, one that enabled the nation's tax-collecting agency to demonstrate a smidgen of human compassion.
"Sometimes pieces of the tax code can be as hard to understand as the infield fly rule," said IRS Commissioner Charles Rossotti. "All I know is that the fan who gives back the home run ball deserves a round of applause, not a big tax bill."
Absolutely. And shame on the IRS, and its cold, tiny heart, for even thinking of it in the first place.
