"Journalistic ethics."
There are those who would, without a doubt, consider that phrase an oxymoron — and, given some of the shenanigans perpetrated by some members of the media over the last few years, such thinking would not be surprising.
The media's cause has not been helped by writers who fabricate stories, or television news crews that doctor experiments. These acts, to just about anyone, are clearly unethical.
One would hope people would recognize that, like any profession, the media has a minority of individuals who do not do the right thing, while many others do. But ask any American which profession is the most hated, and "the media" will often follow shortly after politicians and lawyers.
Apparently, this sentiment is shared abroad — and an international conference running today through Monday in Istanbul, Turkey, is hosting a debate over a proposed international code of journalism ethics, and ways to enforce it.
That latter part is what has set the alarms off in the minds of many American newspaper editors.
In the United States, we consider "ethics" something to be adopted, not enforced — particularly given the language of our Constitution, which states no law shall be enacted that abridges the freedom of the press.
Ethics are voluntary, something one participates in if one is of good character. Ethics are subjective — beyond the obvious points, not everyone may agree on what's ethical. What may violate one man's ethics may not necessarily violate another's.
And not all "ethics violations" are crimes, nor should they be.
Talk of an international code and its enforcement has drawn a stern response from Edward Seaton, president of the American Society of Newspaper Editors:
"The journalists of the world will not and should not be accountable to any self-appointed group," Seaton wrote in a letter to the World Association of Press Councils. "They are responsible only to the news organizations that employ them, which are in turn responsible to their customers, the news-consuming public."
Seaton is correct; and by no means should a code of ethics be considered something that needs to be "enforced."
Further, the news business lends itself to situation ethics; every story, every set of circumstances, is different, and decisions often have to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, hopefully operating from a core belief in doing the right thing. A set of absolute rules cannot necessarily be applied across the board.
But on the flip side, many news gatherers would be well-advised to revisit the reasons they got into the news business in the first place, and evaluate their own set of personal ethics. And if groups or associations of journalists wish to voluntarily adhere to one code of ethics or another, and tout those ethics to their readers, there's no harm in that, either.
Here, at The Signal, we try our level best to conduct ourselves in a way that most citizens would agree is "ethical." Sometimes we may not meet that goal in everyone's eyes, but it is not for a lack of trying. We seek truth, compassion and honest caring for our community's best interests. We don't have a written "ethics code" code for every situation, but the overriding theme is to report the local news truthfully and always seek the betterment of the Santa Clarita Valley.
More than 200 delegates from some 30 nations are in Turkey this weekend, and the ethics code is on their agenda. Let's hope the product is a reasonable set of guidelines that journalists will embrace — voluntarily.
