Here’s how we’re told it’s supposed to work: An issue comes before the voters. They have several months to listen to both sides, for and against. The voters then go to the polls and vote, and depending on how many voters voted and which way they voted, the issue either becomes a law or it doesn’t.
That’s the way it’s supposed to work. It’s in all the text books. You can look it up.
Now here’s the way it really seems to work: An issue comes before the voters, they listen to both sides, they go to the polls and vote. Then, if a collection of well-connected , well-monied , determined business interests doesn’t like the way the vote went, they hire a crew of lawyers to go before the state supreme court, argue as only lawyers can in front of other lawyers now called judges, and get the wishes of the voters overturned.
That’s not in any of the textbooks, but it’s exactly what’s happened with Proposition 5, the legislation that assured California’s Indian nations the right to determine, exclusively on their own land, how they would conduct their gambling businesses. Obviously, the courts must act as part of the system of checks and balances, and if a voter-approved initiative truly flies in the face of the Constitution, it must be set aside. But more and more these days, it seems that the attorneys for the losing side are simply going to court— regardless of the issue— and creatively finding ways to set aside the voters’ wishes.
That’s what happened with Prop. 5.
Last fall, after a hard-fought and expensive publicity campaign, voters heard what the Indian nations had to say, how gambling had helped eradicate decades of poverty, disease and government dependence on California’s reservations.
Voters also listened as the anti-Prop . 5 forces— financed for the most part by Las Vegas gambling interests, who stood to lose a lot of money if gambling dollars stayed in California rather than going to Nevada— accused the tribes of being everything from anti-union to anti-environment .
The voters went to the polls and overwhelmingly passed Prop. 5.
Attorneys for the unions and Las Vegas gambling houses saw their clients stood to lose a major chunk of change. They beat a path to the courts, which overturned Prop. 5, and now Gov. Gray Davis is meeting behind closed doors with Indian tribal leaders, trying to persuade them to accept a compromise plan that could take from them 40 to 60 percent, by some estimates, of their net income from casinos.
Understandably, the tribal leaders are balking at Davis’ plan. As has usually been the case in American history, the Indians clearly understand what the vote on Prop. 5 meant; too bad they’re the only ones.
