The Kentucky State University yearbooks were confiscated, in part, because their covers were purple.
In seizing the 2,000 student-produced yearbooks in 1994, the university’s administration touched off a legal battle that culminated last week when a federal appeals court in Cincinnati ruled that the confiscation was legal.
Citing poor yearbook quality— and that apparently irksome purple cover— the court used a 1988 Supreme Court decision to support its ruling that the seizure of the yearbooks was legal.
That 1988 case, Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier, upheld a high school principal’s censorship of a student newspaper. The Supreme Court ruling allows school administrators to censor material that they find to be to be “ungrammatical,” “poorly written” “inappropriate,” or “inconsistent with the shared values of a civilized social order.”
In other words, these court rulings add up to a restriction on the First Amendment rights of the student press, not only at the high school level but also at the collegiate level.
That’s sticky territory.
The student press, especially at the high school and college levels, should be a place for aspiring writers, editors and photojournalists to not only learn the ropes of their planned professions but also for students of all disciplines to experience and participate in a free and open exchange of ideas. In other words, the student press should be an exercise in the First Amendment.
But one can argue that, in censoring student-produced material, a school administration is merely exercising its own rights under the First Amendment.
The Constitution, after all, does not guarantee everyone the right to a government-subsidized platform for their speech. Rather, it allows for a free press, with any individual outlet, like a newspaper, controlling its own content. In the real world, the First Amendment rights lie with the publisher. If a writer doesn’t agree with the decisions of a publisher, he or she is always free to quit the job and go start his or her own newspaper.
In the student press, the publisher is typically the school itself, with students doing the actual production of the newspaper, yearbook or magazine.
So, in a technical sense, one could argue that the First Amendment rights of students are not violated by these rulings. As that argument goes, students like those in Kentucky are still free to produce their own purple yearbook, provided they do it on their nickel, not the state’s.
However, these rulings are widely decried by First Amendment advocates as an unreasonable restriction on the student press— and an erosion of the First Amendment rights of students.
That’s certainly true from the standpoint of the “spirit” of the First Amendment, and in an ideal learning environment students would be free to publish as they see fit, and to learn from their mistakes without being subjected to iron-fisted editing from a campus administration. And in the spirit of the First Amendment, there’s nothing quite like a college newspaper that rails against the decisions and actions of administrators and school boards. That’s all a vital part of learning about the exercise of our constitutional rights.
Sadly, high school and college administrations everywhere seem to win on a technicality. And if students want to lampoon the administration— or, apparently, publish a yearbook with a purple cover— they may be forced to do it the way it’s done in the real world: Sell some ads and pay for it themselves.
