Some people might consider it a victory of sorts— and not without some cause— but the decision by the Bureau of Land Management’s decision to order a repeat of significant portions of the environmental study for the Transit Mixed Concrete Co.’s mining proposal does not mean the battle is won.
The BLM this week decided the environmental impact statement for the mining plan must be redone with respect to air quality, and perhaps other portions. The BLM also extended the public comment period until Jan. 3— giving opponents of the project more time to research the plan’s flaws and potential impacts.
On the surface, that sounds like a win for the nearly unified opposition the project faces here in the Santa Clarita Valley. And, our own Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, R-Santa Clarita, deserves a pat on the back for getting involved. McKeon’s opposition to the project has certainly called the BLM’s attention to the community’s concerns about it.
It’s a rare proposal that unites such a wide cross-section of the community in opposition. We saw it with the proposed Elsmere Canyon landfill, and we’ve seen it here: There is widespread local objection to the plan to mine 83 million tons of aggregate— used in making concrete— from a 460-acre site near Soledad Canyon and Agua Dulce Canyon roads, just east of Canyon Country.
The project has drawn fire for its potential impacts on traffic, water quality and air quality, and the consensus in the community seems to be that such a large mine so close to already populated areas, directly upslope from a valuable underground water supply, is not a good idea.
Thus, the delay imposed by the BLM is undoubtedly welcomed.
But it does not ensure victory. In fact, the BLM also ordered the new environmental study to take into account the possible benefits of a conveyor system proposed by Transit Mixed to handle mine waste. The BLM indicated the conveyor concept “has merit,” and may alter the project’s impact on air quality.
Regardless, the delay and re-analysis should be viewed as an opportunity by those who hope to defeat the mining proposal. They have been armed with extra time— and they’d be well-advised to use it.
