If you’ve ever had an insurance company representative make a health care decision over the phone instead of the doctor who examined you, odds are you’ll want to thank the state Legislature and Gov. Gray Davis for the package of health care reform bills signed into law Monday.
The new laws give patients some important new weapons in their battles with health maintenance organizations, most notably the right to sue and a requirement that physicians be involved in medical decision-making .
Oddly enough, a new liability law was needed to make California one of three states to give citizens the right to sue HMOs if they are substantially harmed by the insurer’s decision to delay or deny treatment. The right to sue—Êwhile often abused and overused in today’s society— is an important protection for citizens in a variety of arenas.
Further, the reform package requires health insurers to provide a second opinion when a patient requests it. The new laws also order HMOs to cover contraceptives, cancer screening and treatment for diabetes and mental illnesses.
In principle, of course, the government shouldn’t typically regulate to the extent that it requires businesses to provide certain services. On a broad scale, such decisions ought to be dictated by market forces.
However, health care is often a life-or-death service, one that warrants extra attention from the government. And many HMO patients would agree managed-care organizations have a track record of making medical decisions based on the bottom line rather than a patient’s real needs.
The health care reform package signed by Davis is designed to put those decisions back where they belong: In the hands of doctors and patients.
Under the new regulations, HMOs will be required to render most decisions about surgery referrals or specialized care within five days, and the decisions are required to be made by medical professionals— not HMO bean counters.
An independent review system will be established for patients who contend a managed-care plan unfairly denied or delayed treatment, and doctors with no stake in the cases would be called upon to help resolve them.
If a patient disagrees with the outcome of that review, he or she could then sue under the new liability law. Plaintiffs could seek compensatory and punitive damages if they suffered substantial injury as a result of an HMO’s decisions.
There are down sides, of course, to the new rules. Attorneys up and down the state will no doubt salivate over the possibilities, and health care organizations will lament that their costs will increase as a result of a new legal defense burden.
However, the review system presents itself as a mechanism to weed out most cases, by resolving them without litigation. Hopefully, this system will prove effective.
More importantly, the good news is that doctors and patients will now have leverage when dealing with HMOs— a tool that can and should be used to better ensure that good medicine, not good financial sense, is what dictates a patient’s course of care.
