The city is approaching an intersection, and the approach should be made with caution: Santa Clarita is considering the implementation of a camera system that would issue citations to red-light-violating motorists.
The cameras are an effective way of issuing citations without chewing up police resources, since the process is automatic and requires no sheriff’s deputy to be present.
However, the system can best be described as, “shades of Big Brother.”
It’s easy to feel conflicted about such a proposal. We all want safer streets, and running a red light— even if it just means being the last one to “cheat” through a light at the end of a long yellow— is an unsafe behavior. However, it’s unsettling to envision the government monitoring us in our cars and issuing citations without any sort of face-to-face encounter.
The city’s plans could be affected by a lawsuit that has been filed to challenge such systems in Los Angeles, Beverly Hills and West Hollywood. The lawsuit was spurred by a San Diego court ruling that found such citations are invalid because the primary responsibility for issuing them lies not with the government, but with the operator of the camera ticketing system (Lockheed Martin IMS Corp.) It was also found that the operator had a financial incentive to issue as many tickets as possible, because it received $60 for each $271 violation recorded.
Such a system does seem prone to abuse, although that wasn’t necessarily the case in San Diego.
Most observers agree there is a problem in Santa Clarita with motorists running red lights— most commonly in the aforementioned tactic, squeezing just one more car through at the tail end of a yellow light that is actually red already.
But is setting up an automated ticketing system the right answer for Santa Clarita’s problem? Perhaps the courts will make that decision for the city, by virtue of ruling on the three-city lawsuit, but even if Santa Clarita gets a green light to proceed with its plans, it should think long and hard before doing so.
