Politicians are no dummies when it comes to pushing taxpayers' buttons. They know that they can pique voters' interest with rhetoric like, "What we need to do to better our children's education is ..."
So, as the Nov. 3 election approaches, various candidates have hit voters where they live, espousing such concepts as safe schools, higher-quality education and fewer crowded classrooms.
These aren't exactly daring positions — after all, very few people would oppose safer schools, or less crowded classrooms — but what differentiates one politician from another is his or her philosophy on how to get there.
And invariably someone brings up vouchers: A way of reimbursing individuals for a portion of the cost of private education.
It's happened in the gubernatorial race, as Republican candidate Dan Lungren — the state's current attorney general — has come out in favor of vouchers as a means of promoting competition to improve the public school system. His Democratic opponent — Lt. Gov. Gray Davis — counters that private schools aren't equipped to handle a massive influx of new students anyway, so the emphasis needs to be placed on fixing the problems in public schools.
The latter philosophy makes more sense. Why? Because vouchers are a sham.
They are not, contrary to some of their advocates' claims, designed to benefit public education. They are, in fact, designed to benefit those who choose to put their children in private school.
Obviously, a voucher for a private education would help some low-income students afford a better education than they would get at their neighborhood public school. But the numbers of such students would be dwarfed by the numbers of affluent students who would be receiving a taxpayer subsidy for expensive private educations.
Further, the implementation of a voucher system would undoubtedly line the pockets of those who own and operate private schools. It would be naive to think private school tuition would not increase with the passage of a government subsidy.
A voucher system would amount to reverse welfare, a benefit to the elite at the expense of all taxpayers — and it would be refreshing to see a political season come and go in which vouchers are not put forth as a solution to public education's woes.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
