The city made its bed nearly a decade ago— and now it faces little choice but to sleep in it, or at least try to find a more comfortable position.
If they had it to do over again, it’s not difficult to imagine that city staffers and City Council members would have written Santa Clarita’s sign ordinance a little differently.
But the city was just 3 years old when the ordinance was adopted in 1990, and while the sign law has applied to new businesses since then, it is only now coming into effect for businesses that pre-existed the ordinance.
That delay is the result of one entirely reasonable aspect of the ordinance: The city gave business owners nearly a decade to make any signage changes dictated by the ordinance, thus allowing them to not only save up the resources needed to make the switch but also to gain some value out of signs in which they may have already invested.
On its face, a sign ordinance is a reasonable concept; a city is entitled to enact some regulations on the size and height of signage. But businesses are also entitled to have adequate signage to advertise themselves, so any sign ordinance is a delicate balancing act between reasonable regulation and business owners’ rights.
And whether the city’s ordinance strikes that balance is subject to debate. Advocates of the ordinance say it reasonably limits signage in an effort to prevent and diminish visual blight. Opponents, including many business owners stung by the costs and decreased visibility imposed on them by the sign ordinance, say it is unreasonably restrictive and unfair to some businesses that don’t have the location advantages enjoyed by others.
That’s where it gets really sticky: All business locations are not created equal, and it may not be too much to ask for some businesses to be allowed exceptions to the rules. If your business is set back from the street in the recesses of a shopping center, you don’t enjoy the same visibility as a business with a prominent corner location— so you may need more aggressive signage to let potential customers know you’re there.
Given that, the City Council last week adopted some new rules and appeal procedures for businesses seeking variances to the sign ordinance. It remains to be seen whether this will prove to be the salve to take the sting out of the ordinance for some businesses, but at this stage of the game there may not have been much else for the city to do. If the city were to scrap its ordinance and start over, a new group of complainants would emerge: Those businesses that have played by the new rules and replaced their old signage. If the ordinance were scrapped, they would argue— and not without merit— that it was unfair to them because they had already incurred the expense of complying.
That’s the bed Santa Clarita made for itself way back in the early years of cityhood. And it’s firmly tucked between the proverbial rock and a hard place.
