The conflict between the rights of the student press and a school administration played itself out recently at Hart High School— and at the center of the conflict was a package of stories headlined, “Sex: Raw and Uncensored.”
As it turned out, the “uncensored” part wasn’t accurate.
The package of stories was planned for publication by the student staff of The Smoke Signal, the campus newspaper. The stories were on topics ranging from abstinence to peer pressure to “terse data on sexually transmitted diseases.”
The spread also included information on different forms of birth control and quotes from students recalling the first time they “learned” about sex— with responses ranging from someone having “the talk” with Mom or Dad to someone picking up the information from friends.
The Hart High administration invoked its right to restrict content of student-produced publications, and the decision was handed down that the two-page spread was not suitable for The Smoke Signal.
As one might expect, the student journalists were not entirely pleased. As most student journalists do, they intended to provide material that, while perhaps a little provocative, was of interest to their audience.
After the administration’s decision was made, the student paper made plans to publish a two-page spread that was blank, except for the word, “Censored,” emblazoned across it. That’s a powerful word— especially to advocates of the First Amendment. And yes, in this case, government employees censored the content of a publication.
But there’s one fine legal point to remember here: While our First Amendment rights guarantee a free press, they do not guarantee one the right to a government-provided press. And that’s what a student newspaper amounts to. Obviously, the goal of every student newspaper ought to be to provide an experience in which students learn First Amendment values— so it’s important that school administrations meddle as little as possible in the content.
However, the fact remains that the “publisher” of a school newspaper is the school itself. There’s no law preventing the students— or anyone else— from publishing their own newspaper. But when push comes to shove, if the publisher— the administration— deems material unacceptable, that’s the school’s prerogative.
In this particular case, the students, frustrated that their material was censored, came to The Signal. Portions of their material have been published today in “The Zone,” the newspaper’s section devoted to teens and teen issues.
In reading the original package and the pieces written by the students, one can’t help but notice that packaging is a significant factor in how the stories are viewed. The students’ original two-page layout was anchored by a very large headline: “SEX.”
Below that, the subhead, “Raw and uncensored.”
Suppose you’re a high school educator. You’d cringe at that, wouldn’t you?
Once one reads the stories, it becomes clear that the content is not nearly as provocative as its headline treatment. In fact, the stories’ general theme is that abstinence is the way to go— and that, despite all of the information that confronts teens about sex, many of them are planning to wait until they’re older or married before they have sex.
It seems, then, that the appearance of the package— as an all-out exposé on teen sex— was more off-putting than much of the actual content.
It’s no surprise that statistics show more than half of individuals ages 15-19 have had sexual intercourse. But the overriding tone of the students’ articles was one of caution, and advocacy of abstinence, which is undeniably a positive message for teens to send to each other.
So who was right?
In a sense, both sides were— the school exercised its right not to publish something that would have undoubtedly caused a great deal of parental controversy. And, when the students found they couldn’t get their stories published in the school paper, they found another way to exercise their First Amendment rights— by seeking another venue for their articles.
