There are many arguments both pro and con when it comes to Proposition 38, the school voucher initiative, but perhaps the most convincing one of all is a very simple principle:
‘The vouchers would in many cases go to the very people who need them the least: The affluent families who already choose to incur the expense of a private education rather than sending their children to public schools.’
School vouchers would be a government subsidy for the rich.
There are other reasons, too, that you should vote “no” Tuesday on Proposition 38, which would make available $4,000 vouchers, or scholarships, to kindergarten through 12th-grade children who choose private schools.
The reasons to oppose Prop. 38 range from the measure’s potentially devastating impact on public school funding, to the lack of educational accountability for private schools, to the uncertainty of it all.
How much could the voucher initiative cost state taxpayers?
It’s a crapshoot, really. Short-term cost estimates range from nothing on up to $1.1 billion annually, and the long-term impact could range wildly, from $2 billion in costs to $3 billion in savings.
It all depends on how many students take advantage of the voucher option. But one certainty is that Prop. 38 would not at all represent an investment in California public schools. It’s quite the opposite.
Bear in mind that the voucher cost/savings formula isn’t as simple as Prop. 38 advocates would have you believe. Simply because a student leaves public school to go to private school— thus costing the public school his or her daily attendance-based funding— does not mean the school will achieve an equivalent savings as a result of no longer having to educate that child.
The school would still have to provide all of the full services a school provides— everything from libraries to cafeterias to academic and athletic programs— but would have to do it without that lost funding.
At a time when our public schools are in dire need of whatever funds they have, it makes no sense to take dollars away in the form of vouchers.
What’s more, the vouchers would in many cases go to the very people who need them the least: The affluent families who already choose to incur the expense of a private education rather than sending their children to public schools.
Obviously, vouchers could help a few low-income students afford a better education than they would get at their local public school. But the numbers of such students would be dwarfed by the numbers of affluent students who would receive a taxpayer subsidy for expensive private schooling.
And don’t forget the taxpayer-financed benefit for the operators of private schools: Prop. 38 would be a windfall for private school operators, and don’t think for a second that private schools would keep tuition levels flat if Prop. 38 passes. What you can really expect is for private school tuitions to rise, and you may even witness the creation of new private schools created simply to take advantage of the new government subsidy.
Yes, California public schools face a variety of challenges— and there’s obviously room for improvement in the way many schools are run. But Proposition 38 won’t solve those problems. It will exacerbate them.
