Throughout their battle with the management of Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital, the nurses and other employees have raised some apparently valid points.
They have pointed out errors in past management. They have raised concerns about working conditions. They have cited better wages and benefit packages at other hospitals in the area.
As a result of the workers’ unionization, the hospital’s new management has made a credible attempt to strike a compromise with the unions, the California Nurses Association and the
‘All through this controversy, we have believed that both sides share one common goal: To provide quality patient care for the Santa Clarita Valley. We still believe that to be true...’
United Electrical, Radio & Machine Workers of America.
That series of bargaining attempts progressed Friday with an offer that nearly sealed the deal— but the unions again rejected the hospital’s offer, and put hospital management on notice that the nurses and other employees will stage a one-day strike Nov. 22.
Hopefully it won’t come to that. But it’s difficult to blame hospital officials for being puzzled. They have capitulated on most of the issues put forth by the unions, yet no deal has been made.
All through this controversy, we have believed that both sides share one common goal: To provide quality patient care for the Santa Clarita Valley.
We still believe that to be true— but the unions should provide some indication that they’re not only willing to demand, but also willing to bargain.
Negotiation is all about the art of give and take. In these negotiations, it seems like only one side is doing any giving.
The hospital has acquiesced, and this time around caved in to some of the unions’ most significant demands, including a call for a “closed shop” that would require all employees to join the applicable unions, and demands related to the elimination of salary range caps, the preservation of health benefits and premiums, and payouts of unused sick leave.
Hospital officials were, understandably, bewildered when their latest offer was rejected. The unions demanded A, B, C and D, and the hospital, in its view, offered A, B, C and D— just as the unions demanded.
Yet no deal. Union representatives insist that the details of all four demands were not agreed to completely by the hospital. That may be the case, but it seems major concessions have been made by hospital management, and so far the concession street seems to be of the one-way variety.
Both sides have an opportunity Thursday, in one final bargaining session, to avert the threatened Nov. 22 strike. Let’s hope they succeed— and let’s hope both sides come to the bargaining table willing to reach middle ground.
